What is a director's liability for the company's debts?

As a general rule, none. The debts of a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) or a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”) are paid by the company out of its own assets, not by the director or the shareholders. The Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) does, however, provide for two exceptions. The director is liable with their own assets for debts arising after a legal ground for dissolution, such as serious losses, if they do not call the general meeting within two months to dissolve the company or remove that ground. The director is also liable when their own conduct has directly caused loss to the creditor, for example if they close the business in practice and allow the assets that could have been used to pay to disappear.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The general rule and its limits

A limited company and a public limited company have assets separate from those of their shareholders and directors. The director signs on behalf of the company and does not become personally bound, unless they also guarantee the transaction personally, as banks often ask.

That separation has two limits in the Companies Act, which are explained below. They reach whoever is named as a director even if they do not run the business, because whoever accepts the post takes on its duties. They also reach whoever runs the business without being named, the so-called de facto director.

Debts to the tax authorities and to Social Security and the liability that can be declared in insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”), have their own rules, which are a separate matter.

If the director does not dissolve the company when the law requires it

The law requires the company to be dissolved when one of the grounds it lists arises. The most common is losses, when they leave the net assets, which broadly speaking are what the company has minus what it owes, below half of the share capital. Another is the cessation of activity, which is taken to have occurred after more than a year of inactivity.

When one of those grounds arises, the directors have two months to call the general meeting, which will have to resolve to dissolve the company or to adopt measures that remove the ground. If the meeting is not held or adopts neither of those resolutions, they have a further two months to ask the court to order the dissolution. A director who does not do so is liable with their own assets, together with the company, under these rules:

  • The director is liable only for debts arising after the ground for dissolution. The law presumes that the debt claimed arose afterwards, so it is for the director to prove otherwise.
  • If there are several directors, the creditor can claim the whole debt from any of them.
  • A director who accepts the post when the ground already existed has two months from accepting it to call the general meeting and, if they do not, is liable for debts arising after that acceptance.
  • A director is not liable if, within those two months, they apply for the company's insolvency proceedings or notify the court that the company is negotiating a restructuring plan with its creditors.

According to the “Tribunal Supremo”, Spain's Supreme Court, the time limit for claiming against the director by this route is the same as that of the company's debt.

If the director causes direct loss to the creditor

The other route is the so-called individual liability action (“acción individual de responsabilidad”). It allows the creditor to claim from the director the loss the director has directly caused through conduct contrary to the law, the articles of association or the duties of the post. It is not enough that the company does not pay. The creditor must point to what the director did wrong and prove that this is why the debt was not collected. The time limit is four years.

The most frequent case is that of the business that closes without being wound up. The company stops operating without being dissolved or applying for insolvency proceedings and its assets disappear. Such a closure in practice breaches the director's duties, but to hold the director liable by this route the courts require the creditor to identify specific assets from which, in an orderly liquidation, the creditor would have recovered all or part of the debt. If the debt arose when a ground for dissolution already existed, it is usually simpler to claim by the first route, which does not require that proof.

The creditor can claim against the company and the director in the same claim. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.