What is the individual liability action against a director?

It is the claim by which a shareholder or a third party, normally a creditor of the company, asks the director to compensate harm that the director caused directly to them and not to the company's assets. It requires conduct by the director contrary to the law, the articles of association or the duties of the office, and that the harm be a direct result of it. It is not enough that the company has failed to pay a debt. The compensation goes to the person who claims and the limitation period is four years from the day on which the action could first be brought.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

How it differs from the corporate liability action

Directors are liable for the harm they cause by acts or omissions contrary to the law or the articles of association, or by breaching the duties of their office. If it is the company's assets that are harmed, the claim belongs to the company itself and what is recovered goes to it. This is the so-called corporate liability action (“acción social”).

The individual liability action (“acción individual”) protects a person who suffers harm to their own assets, without it passing through the company's. Any shareholder or injured third party may bring it, with no minimum percentage of capital and no resolution of the general meeting. A shareholder who merely sees the value of their quotas (“participaciones”) fall because of poor management has not suffered direct harm, only the knock-on effect of the harm done to the company. Their route is the corporate liability action.

What has to be proved

The claimant has to prove several things at once:

  • Conduct by the director, by act or omission, in the exercise of their office.
  • That the conduct is contrary to the law, the articles of association or the care and loyalty required of them.
  • Direct harm to the claimant's own assets.
  • That the harm is a consequence of the director's conduct.

The non-payment of a company debt is not enough by itself. If it were, the director would always be liable for the company's debts, which is the opposite of what the law intends. The claimant must point to some conduct of the director, other than the non-payment, that explains why the debt was not paid. The courts have found such conduct, for example, in cases such as these:

  • Entering into contracts on the company's behalf when it was already insolvent and knowing that it would not be able to pay.
  • Stripping the company's assets for the director's own benefit or that of connected persons or companies.
  • Closing the business in practice, without liquidating it, where it is proved that it had specific assets with which all or part of the debt would have been paid.

Something different is the director's liability for debts arising after a legal ground for dissolution that the director failed to deal with. It has its own requirements and is a separate matter.

Limitation period and how to claim

The limitation period is four years from the day on which the action could first be brought. The action is brought against the director, including a de facto director who does not appear in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). If several people were involved, they are jointly and severally liable.

The claim is filed with the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”). The creditor may claim the debt from the company and compensation from the director in the same claim. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.