Can a business unit be sold without insolvency proceedings?

Yes, a company can sell a business or part of one without being in insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), like any other sale. It can also do so within a restructuring plan, which is the agreement with creditors that the law regulates in order to avoid insolvency proceedings. But the advantages of a sale in insolvency proceedings, such as the buyer not taking on the earlier debts, do not exist in an ordinary sale. That is why the law allows the sale to be prepared before the insolvency proceedings so that it can be completed as soon as they are declared, which is known as a “pre-pack”. If the company ends up in insolvency proceedings, an earlier sale that harmed its creditors may be set aside.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Selling outside insolvency proceedings

Outside insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), selling a business is an ordinary sale and the buyer does not have the benefit of the rules that protect it in insolvency proceedings. Depending on the rules governing each area, the buyer may be liable for some of the business's debts, such as tax or employment debts, which are a separate matter. Contracts and licences pass to the buyer on the terms allowed by the rules that govern them and by the contracts themselves, which often require the other party's consent. Micro-enterprises have their own special insolvency procedure, in which the sale of the business follows rules similar to those of insolvency proceedings.

If the company is eventually declared insolvent, acts carried out in the two years before the petition for insolvency proceedings that harmed its creditors can be set aside, even if there was no intention to defraud. This is known as avoidance or clawback (“rescisión”), which is normally sought by the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”). If the company had notified the court that it was negotiating with its creditors and did not obtain a court-confirmed plan, acts carried out in the two years before that notice can also be set aside. If the buyer is a person specially related to the company, such as a shareholder with at least 10 % of the capital or a relative of theirs, a director or a company in the group, the law presumes that harm unless the contrary is proved. It is therefore advisable to sell at market price, with an independent valuation and offering the transaction to other interested parties.

The sale can also be included in a restructuring plan. If the judge confirms the plan, that is, approves it, acts that are reasonable and immediately necessary to implement it are protected against avoidance in subsequent insolvency proceedings, except in the case of fraud. For this, the claims affected by the plan must amount to at least 51 % of all the company's debts.

The pre-pack

A pre-pack consists of preparing the sale before the insolvency proceedings in order to complete it within them. The law offers two options:

  • Applying for the appointment of an expert. If it is foreseeable that the company will be unable to pay its debts regularly, or if it can no longer do so, the judge who would have jurisdiction over its insolvency proceedings can be asked to appoint an expert to look for buyers who will pay in cash, even if the business has stopped operating. The appointment is confidential. The buyer cannot be acting on behalf of the company itself and must undertake to maintain or resume the business for at least two years.
  • Filing the offer with the petition for insolvency proceedings. The company attaches the written and binding offer of a creditor or a third party, who undertakes to maintain or resume the business for at least three years. When declaring the insolvency, the judge allows fifteen days for the creditors to make observations and for any interested party to submit alternative offers. The judge then approves the one most advantageous to the insolvency proceedings.

Appointing the expert does not exempt the company from petitioning for insolvency proceedings within the two months following the date on which it became aware, or should have become aware, that it cannot pay its debts. If insolvency proceedings are later declared, they are handled by the same judge, who may turn the expert into the insolvency practitioner.

The Barcelona commercial court judges approved guidelines for handling pre-packs in January 2021, when the law did not yet regulate them. Today, in Barcelona, it is a criterion agreed by the judges of the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”) that the expert should supervise the search for buyers without conducting it personally and should report at the end on whether the proposed buyer is the best available.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.