What are the requirements for the sale of a business unit?
In insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), the business unit is sold as a whole, under the judge's control and, as a general rule, by electronic auction, although the judge may authorise a direct sale. Offers must identify the buyer and its solvency and specify what is being bought, the price, the method of payment and the guarantees. Before deciding, the judge hears the employees' representatives, if there are any. If the unit includes mortgaged or pledged assets that are sold free of the security and the price does not cover their value, the agreement of a qualified majority of the creditors holding that security is also required.
Alburquerque Abogados
How it is sold
Until a composition with creditors (“convenio”) is approved or the liquidation stage is opened, the sale of a business unit needs the judge's authorisation and is made by electronic auction, unless the judge authorises another method. At any point in the insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), or if the auction attracts no bids, the judge may authorise by order a direct sale or a sale through a specialised person or entity.
Once the liquidation stage has been opened, the sale is made by the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”), who is the professional appointed by the judge to run the insolvency proceedings. The practitioner sells the unit as a whole, unless the judge authorises selling it in parts. If its value exceeds 5 % of the total value of the assets in the inventory, the practitioner sells it by electronic auction, unless the judge has laid down other rules.
At any stage, before ruling on the sale, the judge must give the employees' representatives, if there are any, fifteen days in which to be heard. The employment consequences of the sale are a separate matter.
In Barcelona, it is a criterion agreed by the judges of the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”) that, whatever the method of sale, the insolvency practitioner should explain why selling the business unit benefits the creditors more than liquidating its assets separately and should give the sale the publicity needed to attract as many buyers as possible.
The offers
The insolvency practitioner sets the period for submitting offers and, before it begins, specifies the costs of keeping the business running until the award. Each offer must contain at least the following:
- The identity of the buyer and information on its solvency and on its human and technical resources.
- A precise list of the assets, rights, contracts, licences and authorisations it includes.
- The price, the method of payment and the guarantees. If there are assets subject to a mortgage or a pledge, the price with the security and without it.
- Its effect on the employees.
In an auction, the judge may award the unit to an offer up to 15 % lower than the highest one if it better secures the continuity of the business and of jobs and better and faster payment of the creditors. If the offer is filed with the petition for insolvency proceedings or is obtained beforehand by an expert appointed by the judge, the buyer must also undertake to maintain or resume the business for a minimum of three or two years, depending on the case.
Assets subject to a mortgage or pledge
If the unit includes assets subject to a mortgage or a pledge, which is security over movable property or rights, the law offers two options:
- Selling them free of the security. The secured creditor receives the part of the price that corresponds to the value of its asset within the whole. If the part of the price allocated to it does not reach the value of its security, the sale requires the agreement of the secured creditors who can enforce their security separately and who represent at least 75 % of the secured debt of their class affected by the sale. Whatever remains unpaid is recognised in the insolvency proceedings in the class that corresponds to it.
- Selling them with the security. The buyer takes on the secured debt without the creditor's consent being needed, although the judge must check that the buyer is able to pay it. If that debt is owed to the tax authorities or to Social Security, the buyer does not take it on, even though the security remains in place.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.