Can a property be sold in insolvency proceedings?
Yes, but not freely. Until a composition with creditors (“convenio”) is approved or liquidation is opened, the assets of a debtor in insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”), such as a home, an industrial unit or commercial premises, can only be sold with the judge's authorisation, subject to a few exceptions. In the liquidation, the insolvency practitioner sells them without asking permission for each sale, although the most valuable ones are, in principle, sold by electronic auction. The buyer receives the asset free of the charges predating the insolvency proceedings that secured the debtor's debts, such as mortgages or attachments, because the judge orders them to be discharged, unless the asset is sold subject to the mortgage.
Alburquerque Abogados
Before liquidation
From the insolvency order until a composition is approved or liquidation is opened, the debtor's assets cannot be sold or encumbered without the judge's authorisation. It makes no difference whether the debtor continues to manage them under the supervision of the insolvency practitioner or the insolvency practitioner has replaced the debtor.
No authorisation is needed in these cases:
- Transactions forming part of the debtor's business activity, such as selling the goods it trades in.
- Those that are essential to meet the cash needs of the insolvency proceedings or to keep the debtor's establishments viable.
- The sale of assets not needed for the business when there is an offer that substantially matches the value given to them in the inventory, under the conditions laid down by law.
In the liquidation and if the asset is mortgaged
Once liquidation has been opened, the insolvency practitioner sells the assets in the way that best serves the insolvency proceedings, subject to any special rules the judge may have laid down. No court authorisation is needed for each sale. Assets or lots worth more than 5 % of the total inventoried are sold by electronic auction, on the “Portal de Subastas”, the auction portal of the “BOE”, Spain's Official State Gazette, or on another specialised portal, unless those rules provide otherwise. The others can be sold directly or by other means.
If the property is mortgaged or pledged and is sold within the insolvency proceedings, the insolvency practitioner sells it by electronic auction, unless the judge authorises another method. The judge may authorise, for example, a direct sale to someone who offers more than the minimum price agreed in the security and pays in cash, or the transfer of the asset to the creditor in payment of its claim. The secured creditor is paid out of the proceeds up to the amount owed to it. Any surplus remains in the insolvency estate and any shortfall is recognised as a claim in the insolvency proceedings in the appropriate class.
If you are the buyer
Anyone interested who meets the conditions in the notice can bid at the auction. The insolvency practitioner, on the other hand, cannot buy assets belonging to the insolvency estate, either directly or through another person.
Anyone who buys an asset in insolvency proceedings acquires it free of the charges predating the proceedings that secured insolvency claims, such as mortgages or attachments. The judge orders them to be discharged in the decision approving the sale, whether the asset is sold on its own, in a lot or together with the business. The costs of discharging them are paid by the buyer.
The exception is a sale subject to the mortgage, which the judge can authorise at the insolvency practitioner's request. In that case the mortgage remains in place and the buyer takes over the debt it secures, except for debts owed to the tax authorities or to Social Security, where the law does not allow the buyer to become the debtor. It is advisable to read the terms of the sale carefully, because the discharge only covers those charges and not others.
Sales that the debtor made before the insolvency proceedings are a separate matter. The insolvency practitioner can apply to have set aside those that harmed the debtor's assets and were made in the two years before the petition.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.