What is the liquidation process in insolvency proceedings?
It is the stage of insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) in which the debtor's assets are sold to pay the creditors with the proceeds, in the order set by law. It is opened, among other circumstances, when there is no composition with creditors (“convenio”), when an approved composition is not complied with or when the debtor applies for it, which the debtor can do at any time. It is run by the insolvency practitioner, who replaces the debtor and sells the assets in the way that best serves the insolvency proceedings, subject to any special rules the judge may have laid down. If the debtor is a company, liquidation entails its dissolution.
Alburquerque Abogados
When it is opened and what changes
Liquidation is opened in these cases:
- At the debtor's request, at any time. If the debtor is performing a composition, they must request it as soon as they know they will not be able to make the payments committed to.
- At the request of the insolvency practitioner, if the debtor ceases all or part of its business activity.
- By decision of the judge, without anyone requesting it, if no proposed composition is submitted or it is not admitted, if none is accepted or if the composition is rejected, annulled or breached.
When liquidation is opened, a debtor who is an individual is removed from the management of their assets, which passes to the insolvency practitioner. If the debtor is a company, the judge declares it dissolved if it has not already been dissolved. Its directors leave office and are replaced by the insolvency practitioner, although they continue to represent the company in the proceedings. In addition, deferred debts fall due immediately and those that do not consist of money are converted into money.
How the assets are sold
The judge can lay down special rules for the liquidation, after hearing the insolvency practitioner. Those rules cannot require prior court authorisation for each sale or extend the liquidation beyond a year.
In the absence of special rules providing otherwise, the insolvency practitioner sells the assets in the way that best serves the interests of the insolvency proceedings, within these limits:
- Establishments, operations and other business units are sold together, as a whole, unless the judge authorises selling them separately.
- Assets or lots worth more than 5 % of the total inventoried are sold by electronic auction, on the “Portal de Subastas”, the auction portal of the “BOE”, Spain's Official State Gazette, or on another specialised portal, unless the judge has decided otherwise in the special rules.
The insolvency practitioner reports to the judge every three months on the progress of the liquidation. If a year passes after the opening without the liquidation having been completed, any interested party can ask for the insolvency practitioner to be removed from office. The judge orders the removal unless there is a reason that justifies the delay.
If nobody buys and how it ends
If nobody bids at the auction of a mortgaged or pledged asset, the creditor holding that security can have it awarded to them under the conditions laid down by procedural law. If the creditor does not do so and, according to the inventory, the asset is worth less than the debt, the judge awards it to the creditor at that value. If it is worth more, a further auction is held with no minimum price.
Assets that have no market value, or whose sale would clearly cost more than it would bring in, are identified as such in the final report. The insolvency practitioner submits it within a month of the end of the liquidation and asks in it for the insolvency proceedings to be closed.
The proceeds are used to pay the creditors in the statutory order. Those with security, such as a mortgage, are paid out of what is obtained for the encumbered asset. Out of the rest, the debts that arose during the insolvency proceedings are paid first and then the claims with general priority, the ordinary claims and, lastly, the subordinated claims. The details of the order of payment and what happens to the debtor when the insolvency proceedings end are a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.