Is it possible to get out of insolvency proceedings?
Yes. The usual way out without closing the business is a composition with creditors (“convenio”), an agreement with the creditors approved by the judge that reduces or postpones the debts. From the time it takes effect, the restrictions of the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”), which close once the composition has been fulfilled, come to an end. The proceedings also end if everything owed is paid or paid into court, if the creditors withdraw or waive their claims and in certain other cases provided for by law. If there is neither a composition nor payment, liquidation is opened and the company does not continue, although its business can carry on in the hands of whoever buys it.
Alburquerque Abogados
The composition, the way out that keeps the business going
A composition allows the debtor to continue trading and keep its business. It can be proposed by the debtor or by the creditors whose claims exceed one fifth of the total debts. It must contain a write-down (“quita”), which is a reduction of the debts, a payment deferral (“espera”), which is a postponement of up to ten years, or both. It is accompanied by a payment plan and, where the payments depend on what the business generates, by a viability plan. It is accepted through the written adherence of creditors who make up the majority required by law for its content and is then approved by the judge.
From the time the composition takes effect, generally from the judgment approving it, the effects of the insolvency proceedings end and are replaced by those of the composition itself. The debtor regains the management of its assets, subject to any limits the composition lays down. The insolvency practitioner leaves office.
The insolvency proceedings are closed when the debtor has fulfilled the composition, the judge has declared this and two months have passed since the last publication of that declaration without anyone reporting a breach. If the composition is breached, liquidation is opened. If, after two years, there is a risk of it being breached for a reason not attributable to the debtor, the debtor can propose amending it, once only, provided this is essential for the business to remain viable.
Other ways of ending the insolvency proceedings
The law also provides for the insolvency proceedings to end, without a composition or liquidation, in these cases:
- When, at any point in the proceedings, it is established that everything owed to the recognised creditors has been paid or paid into court or that they have been satisfied in full by other means.
- When, after the end of the common stage (“fase común”), which is the first part of the insolvency proceedings, the recognised creditors withdraw or waive their claims and the judge accepts this.
- When the “Audiencia Provincial”, the provincial appeal court, overturns the insolvency order on appeal.
- When the final list of creditors shows that there is only one.
When liquidation is the only way out
If there is no composition, if the one approved is not complied with or if the debtor applies for it, liquidation is opened, in which the assets are sold to pay the creditors. A company does not come out of liquidation to carry on operating, because the opening of liquidation entails its dissolution. Its business, on the other hand, can continue in someone else's hands if it is sold as a whole, as a business unit, which is a separate matter. So is what happens to the debts that remain when the insolvency proceedings end.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.