What is the composition stage of insolvency proceedings?

It is the part of insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) devoted to processing the composition with creditors (“convenio”), an agreement between the debtor and the creditors, approved by the judge, that sets out how the debts will be paid. It must contain a write-down (“quita”), which is a reduction of the debts, a payment deferral (“espera”), which is a postponement of up to ten years, or both. It is accepted through the written adherence of creditors who make up the majority required by law, without any need to bring them together at a meeting. Once approved, it also binds the ordinary creditors who did not adhere to it or who objected to it and, if the debtor does not comply with it, liquidation is opened.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Who proposes it and how it is accepted

The debtor can submit a proposal with the petition for insolvency proceedings or later, provided that fifteen days have not yet passed since the insolvency practitioner filed their report with the inventory and the list of creditors. Within the same period, creditors whose claims, alone or together, exceed one fifth of the total debts can submit their own. There can be no composition if the debtor has already applied for liquidation.

The proposal is accompanied by a payment plan and, if meeting it relies on what the business generates, by a viability plan. The insolvency practitioner assesses it within ten days and gives an opinion on whether it is feasible to carry it out. Once the proposal has been admitted, the creditors have two months to adhere to it or to object to it in writing, a period that can be extended.

The majority is calculated on the ordinary liabilities, which include the ordinary debts and also the priority debts of the creditors who adhere. Depending on the content of the proposal, it is as follows:

  • If the proposal provides for paying all the ordinary debts within up to three years, or for paying those already due immediately with a write-down of less than 20 % and the rest as they fall due, it is enough for the debts of those who adhere to exceed those of the creditors who object.
  • If it contains write-downs of up to half or deferrals of up to five years, the adherence of more than 50 % of the ordinary liabilities is required.
  • With any other content, such as larger write-downs or longer deferrals, 65 % of the ordinary liabilities is required.

Adhering is not compulsory. Subordinated creditors, who are the last to be paid, cannot do so.

Approval by the judge and its effects

Once the result has been announced, the creditors who did not adhere and the insolvency practitioner can object to approval within ten days, but only on the grounds set by law. One is that the objecting creditor would receive more in a liquidation carried out within the following two years. Another, which may be raised by the insolvency practitioner or by creditors holding at least 5 % of the ordinary claims, is that performance is objectively unfeasible. The judge cannot amend the composition. The judge approves or rejects it in a judgment.

Once approved, the composition binds the debtor and all ordinary and subordinated creditors in respect of their claims predating the insolvency proceedings, even if they did not adhere to it or objected to it. Their claims are reduced by the write-down and postponed by the deferral. The exception is debts for Social Security contributions for common and occupational contingencies, on which the composition cannot impose write-downs or deferrals. Creditors with priority claims, such as those holding a mortgage, are only bound if they adhere or if, within their class, it is accepted by the holders of 60 % or 75 % of those claims, depending on the content.

From the time the composition takes effect, generally from the date of the judgment, the effects of the insolvency proceedings end and are replaced by those of the composition itself. The insolvency practitioner also leaves office.

When the debtor has fulfilled it, they ask the judge to declare that it has been fulfilled. If nobody reports a breach within two months of the last publication of that declaration, the judge declares the insolvency proceedings closed. If the debtor does not fulfil it, any affected creditor can ask for a declaration of breach. If the judge makes that declaration, the composition is terminated, liquidation is opened and the agreed write-downs and deferrals cease to have effect.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.