When does the insolvency practitioner leave office?
As a general rule, when the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) are closed, after the insolvency practitioner has accounted for their management. They also leave office when the composition with creditors (“convenio”) approved by the judge begins to take effect, although they return to office, or someone else is appointed, if liquidation is later opened. Before then, they only leave office if the judge removes them for just cause, if a challenge (“recusación”) against them succeeds or if they resign for a serious reason. In those cases, the judge immediately appoints a replacement and the outgoing insolvency practitioner must account for their management within a month.
Alburquerque Abogados
At the end of the proceedings or with a composition
When the judge declares the insolvency proceedings closed, for example because the assets have been liquidated or because all the creditors have been paid, the restrictions on the debtor end and the insolvency practitioner also leaves office. Before that, they must have submitted their accounts (“rendición de cuentas”), in which they justify how they have used their powers and set out the transactions, the payments and the remuneration they have received.
The debtor and the creditors can object to the approval of those accounts. If the judge does not approve them, the insolvency practitioner is barred from being appointed in other insolvency proceedings for a period of between six months and two years. Neither the approval nor the disapproval of the accounts decides the insolvency practitioner's liability, which is dealt with separately.
If the insolvency is resolved with a composition, the insolvency practitioner leaves office when the composition takes effect, which is generally the date of the judgment approving it. They account for their management within the period set by the judge, but they keep their standing to pursue any interlocutory applications (“incidentes”) under way and to act in the culpability section (“sección de calificación”), which is the part of the proceedings that decides whether the insolvency is culpable. If the composition is breached and liquidation is opened, the judge reinstates them or appoints someone else.
Grounds for leaving office early
Before then, the insolvency practitioner only leaves office for one of these reasons:
- Removal for just cause. The judge can order it on the court's own initiative or at the request of anyone entitled to petition for insolvency proceedings, such as the debtor or any creditor. A serious breach of the duty of care and any breach of the duty of impartiality and independence are always grounds for removal, although the judge may keep the insolvency practitioner in office if objective circumstances make this advisable.
- Removal because the liquidation is taking too long. If a year passes after it was opened without it being completed, any interested party can request removal. The judge orders it, after hearing the insolvency practitioner, unless there is a reason that justifies the delay. An insolvency practitioner removed on this ground loses the right to their remuneration and must repay whatever they have received since the liquidation was opened.
- Challenge. The debtor or a creditor can challenge the insolvency practitioner if there is a ground of incompatibility or a prohibition, such as having provided professional services to the debtor in the previous three years. While the challenge is being decided, the insolvency practitioner continues to act.
- Resignation. Once they have accepted the appointment, they can only resign for a serious reason or because they no longer meet the required conditions.
What happens when the insolvency practitioner leaves office
When the insolvency practitioner leaves office through removal, challenge or resignation, the judge immediately appoints a replacement, with the same publicity as the original appointment. The outgoing insolvency practitioner must submit full accounts within a month.
Decisions on an insolvency practitioner leaving office can be challenged by an application for review (“recurso de reposición”) and then by an appeal, which does not suspend the change of insolvency practitioner. The debtor, the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”), the practitioner affected and anyone who shows a legitimate interest can appeal.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.