Who appoints the insolvency practitioner (“administrador concursal”)?

The insolvency practitioner (“administrador concursal”) is appointed by the insolvency judge, that is, the judge of the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”), in the same order in which the judge declares the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) open. The debtor and the creditors do not choose the practitioner, although they can challenge the appointment if any of the grounds laid down by law applies. The judge selects the practitioner from among the professionals on the lists kept for that purpose, seeking to share out appointments fairly, unless the proceedings call for special experience or training. The practitioner must be a lawyer, an economist, a business studies graduate (“titulado mercantil”) or an auditor with experience and training in insolvency matters, or a firm that brings together a lawyer and one of those other professionals.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

How the judge chooses the practitioner

The appointment forms part of the order declaring the insolvency (“concurso de acreedores”), which also states what powers the insolvency practitioner (“administrador concursal”) has, that is, whether they merely supervise the debtor's acts or replace the debtor in managing its assets. The decision is taken by the judge of the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”), who hears the insolvency proceedings of any debtor, whether a company, a self-employed person or a private individual.

The courts keep lists of the professionals who have declared themselves available for the role and can show training in insolvency matters. The rule is that the judge shares out appointments fairly among those on the lists. The judge can depart from that rotation and appoint a specific person, giving reasons, when the proceedings call for special experience or knowledge, for example to ensure that the company's business continues or because the proceedings are complex.

As a general rule, the office of insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”) is held by a single person, who must meet one of these conditions:

  • Being a practising lawyer, with five years of actual professional experience and specialist training in insolvency law.
  • Being an economist, a business studies graduate (“titulado mercantil”) or an auditor, with five years of professional experience and demonstrable specialisation in insolvency matters.
  • Being a firm that includes at least one practising lawyer and one economist, business studies graduate or auditor and that guarantees the independence and commitment the role demands.

Who cannot be appointed and how the appointment can be challenged

To ensure impartiality, the law prevents the appointment of, among others, anyone who has provided professional services of any kind to the debtor in the previous three years, anyone who has been removed from that office in the previous three years and anyone who is disqualified. The appointee has five days to accept and must have liability insurance or an equivalent guarantee. If they do not accept, the judge appoints someone else immediately.

Those who can petition for insolvency proceedings, such as the debtor or any creditor, can challenge the insolvency practitioner if one of those grounds applies or one of the grounds on which a court expert can be challenged. This must be done as soon as the ground becomes known. The challenge is dealt with as an interlocutory application (“incidente”) within the insolvency proceedings and, while it is being decided, the practitioner concerned continues to act. Decisions on the appointment can also be challenged by an application for review (the “recurso de reposición”) and then by an appeal, which does not suspend the appointment.

There are procedures in which an insolvency practitioner is not always appointed. In insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”), which, broadly speaking, are those of a debtor without enough assets even to pay the costs of the procedure itself, one is only appointed if creditors representing at least 5 % of the debts ask for it, for the sole purpose of drawing up a report. In the special procedure for micro-enterprises, the practitioner's involvement is limited to certain cases.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.