What happens if an SL cannot pay its debts?

The company remains the debtor and is liable for its debts with all its assets, but the shareholders do not pay them out of their own assets, unless they have guaranteed them or in certain exceptional cases. The creditors can claim payment from it and have its assets attached. If the defaults become widespread, any of them can petition for insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) against it. When the company can no longer meet its obligations regularly, the directors have two months to petition for insolvency proceedings or, if it is a micro-enterprise, to apply for the special procedure provided for micro-enterprises. Within that period or, better still, before reaching that point, they can notify the court that they are negotiating with the creditors, which is known as the pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”), in order to try to reach an agreement with them.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Who is liable for the debts

A limited company (“sociedad limitada” or SL) has assets that are separate from those of its shareholders. The debts belong to the company, which is liable for them with all its assets, present and future. The shareholders risk what they contributed, but they are not personally liable, unless they have guaranteed a specific debt, as banks often require when granting a loan. There is another exception if the company's share capital is less than 3.000 euros. When, on its liquidation, its assets are not enough to pay the debts, any of the shareholders may have to pay the difference between the capital and those 3.000 euros.

Nor are the directors liable merely because the company does not pay. The law makes them liable in certain cases, above all if they fail to react in time to serious losses or to insolvency, which is a separate matter.

What the creditors can do

Each creditor can bring a court claim for what it is owed and, with a judgment or another enforceable instrument, have the company's money, receivables or assets attached. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.

When the defaults are no longer isolated, any creditor can ask the judge to make an insolvency order (the court's declaration opening the proceedings) against the company. To do so, it must prove one of the facts that the law regards as indicative of insolvency, such as widespread non-payment of current debts, attachments affecting the company's assets as a whole or widespread non-payment of taxes, Social Security contributions or wages over the previous three months.

What the directors must do

While the company can still pay, even if it foresees that it will stop doing so, the directors can negotiate deferrals or reductions with the creditors. They can also notify the court of the opening of negotiations with them, the so-called pre-insolvency stage, which for a few months halts much of the enforcement against the assets needed for the business while an agreement, which the law calls a restructuring plan, is negotiated.

When the company can no longer regularly meet its obligations as they fall due, it is in actual insolvency. The directors must then petition for insolvency proceedings within two months of the date on which they knew, or should have known, of that situation. Within that period they can still opt for the pre-insolvency stage, unless a creditor's petition for insolvency proceedings has already been admitted. If no agreement is reached and the insolvency continues, they will have to petition for insolvency proceedings within a month of the protection ending.

Failing to petition for insolvency proceedings in time gives rise to a presumption, unless the contrary is proved, of wilful misconduct or gross negligence, which may lead to the insolvency being classified as culpable, with personal consequences for the directors.

If the company is a micro-enterprise, that is, if in the previous year it had on average fewer than ten employees and it has a turnover of less than 700.000 euros or liabilities of less than 350.000 euros, the law provides a special procedure for it, with its own rules, instead of insolvency proceedings and the pre-insolvency stage. That is the procedure its directors must apply for within that two-month period and the one its creditors can apply for. Before applying for it, the company can also notify the court that it is negotiating with its creditors, although with shorter time limits than those of the pre-insolvency stage.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.