What are creditor-initiated insolvency proceedings (“concurso necesario”)?

They are insolvency proceedings opened at the request of someone other than the debtor, usually a creditor who is not being paid and believes the debtor cannot pay anyone. They differ from voluntary insolvency proceedings, which are those the debtor itself petitions for. Whoever petitions must prove one of the facts that, under Spain's Insolvency Act (“Ley Concursal”), reveal insolvency, such as a general failure to pay debts or attachments affecting all of the debtor's assets. The debtor can object. If the judge makes the insolvency order, the insolvency practitioner in principle takes over the management of the debtor's assets and the creditor who petitioned gains priority for payment of half of its claim.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Creditor-initiated or voluntary

The consolidated Insolvency Act (“texto refundido de la Ley Concursal”) calls insolvency proceedings voluntary when the first petition filed is the debtor's own. In all other cases they are creditor-initiated (“concurso necesario”). It is usually a creditor who petitions, although the law also allows other persons to do so, which is another matter.

If the debtor is a micro-enterprise, that is, if it carries on a business or professional activity, has fewer than ten employees and has a turnover below 700.000 euros or debts below 350.000 euros, it cannot be subject to insolvency proceedings, whether voluntary or creditor-initiated. The law makes it subject exclusively to a special procedure for micro-enterprises.

There is one case in which the proceedings are treated as creditor-initiated even though the debtor petitions for them. This happens when, in the three months before the debtor's petition, another person entitled to do so had already petitioned for insolvency proceedings and the judge had admitted that petition for processing, even if that person then withdrew it, failed to appear or did not ratify it.

For the debtor, the difference matters. Anyone who is insolvent, that is, unable to pay their debts regularly, has a duty to petition for their own insolvency proceedings within two months of the date on which they became aware, or should have become aware, of their insolvency. If a creditor gets there first because the debtor failed to comply with that duty, the law presumes, unless the contrary is proved, that the insolvency is culpable, that is, that it was caused or aggravated through wilful misconduct or gross negligence. That has consequences for the debtor and, if it is a company, for its directors, which are another matter.

What changes in creditor-initiated proceedings

Once the insolvency order has been made, these are the most visible differences from voluntary proceedings:

  • The management of the assets. In voluntary proceedings, the debtor continues to manage its assets, but its decisions require the authorisation of the insolvency practitioner, who is the professional the judge appoints to act in the insolvency proceedings. In creditor-initiated proceedings, as a rule, those powers are suspended and the insolvency practitioner takes the debtor's place. The judge can order otherwise in either case by explaining why.
  • The documents. The debtor has ten days from being notified of the insolvency order to file the same documents it would have had to provide if it had petitioned itself, such as the inventory of its assets and the list of its creditors.
  • The claim of the creditor who petitioned. Half of its amount acquires general priority, which gives it preference for payment over ordinary creditors, unless it is one of the claims that the law pays last.

When it may be in the creditor's interest

Petitioning for insolvency proceedings is not a way of being paid separately. Once they are opened, the creditor who petitioned is paid along with the others and in the order laid down by law, with the advantage of the priority on half of its claim.

It can make sense when the debtor carries on trading while failing to pay everyone or when there are signs that it is disposing of its assets. Insolvency proceedings place its assets under the control of the insolvency practitioner and make it possible to seek the setting aside of acts detrimental to creditors that the debtor carried out in the two years before the petition.

It also carries risks. If the judge rejects the petition, the creditor may have to pay the costs and compensate the debtor for any damage caused to it. Before petitioning, it is advisable to find out what assets the debtor has, because if there is nothing to distribute, insolvency proceedings do not improve the prospects of payment.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.