Who pays the costs of creditor-initiated insolvency proceedings (“concurso necesario”)?

It depends on how the petition ends. If the judge makes the insolvency order, the costs of the creditor who petitioned are paid out of the debtor's assets as a claim against the estate, which is a debt paid before the claims of the insolvency creditors. If the judge rejects the petition, as a general rule the creditor must pay the debtor's costs. It does not pay them if the judge finds, giving reasons, that the case raised serious doubts or, unless there was recklessness (“temeridad”) or bad faith, if its claim had fallen due at least six months before it petitioned. In addition, once the rejection is final, the debtor can claim from the creditor any damage the petition has caused it.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

What costs are

Costs are the part of the expenses of a court case that the law allows to be passed on to another party. They are mainly the fees of the lawyer and the court agent (“procurador”), whose involvement is compulsory to petition for insolvency proceedings. They also include the court fee when one is payable. To petition for creditor-initiated insolvency proceedings (“concurso necesario”), the State fee is 200 euros if the petitioner is a company. Individuals do not pay it.

While the proceedings last, each party pays its own expenses. What the judge decides is whether one of them has to reimburse the other for its expenses.

If the judge makes the insolvency order

The costs of the creditor who petitioned, like those of any person other than the debtor who has petitioned, are treated as a claim against the estate. They are paid out of the insolvent debtor's assets as they fall due, before the claims of the insolvency creditors. This also applies when the debtor does not object or accepts the petition, because the insolvency proceedings are still opened at the creditor's request.

The risk is that the assets may not be enough. If the insolvency practitioner, who is the professional the judge appoints to act in the insolvency proceedings, reports that there are not enough assets to pay all the claims against the estate, the law sets an order of payment among them and these costs may go wholly or partly unpaid.

If the judge rejects the petition

The order rejecting the petition makes the creditor who filed it pay the costs, except in two cases:

  • Serious doubts. The judge may decide not to impose them if the case raised serious doubts of fact or law and the order gives the reasons.
  • The overdue claim. A creditor whose claim had been due for at least six months when it filed the petition is not ordered to pay costs, unless it acted with recklessness (“temeridad”) or in bad faith.

Costs are not the only risk. Once the decision rejecting the petition is final, the debtor can ask the same judge to assess the damages the petition caused it, with a detailed list and whatever evidence it has. If they are assessed and the creditor does not pay them, payment is immediately enforced against the creditor. The law does not make this compensation conditional on the creditor's bad faith, although the debtor must prove the damage and its amount.

That is why it is advisable to petition for insolvency proceedings only when there is solid evidence of the fact that reveals the debtor's insolvency.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.