Who gets paid first in insolvency proceedings?

In insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), creditors are not paid in order of arrival, but according to the class of each claim, which is set by law. Out of whatever is obtained from a mortgaged or pledged asset, the creditor holding that security is paid first. From the other assets, payment goes first to the claims against the estate, which are mainly those arising after the insolvency order, such as the costs of the proceedings themselves or the invoices of suppliers who continue to supply the company. The other creditors are then paid by class, first the priority creditors, then the ordinary creditors and finally the subordinated creditors, who rarely end up being paid.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

First, the claims against the estate

Claims against the estate are not part of the distribution among the creditors in the insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”). They are paid separately, as a general rule as they fall due, out of the assets that are not mortgaged or pledged.

Claims against the estate include the following, among others:

  • The costs of the proceedings, such as the fees of the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”), who is the professional appointed by the judge to run the insolvency proceedings, or the fees of the company's lawyer and court agent (“procurador”).
  • The debts the company incurs by continuing to trade after the insolvency order.
  • What the company owes under contracts that remain in force after the order, such as a supply contract or a lease, for what it receives from then on.
  • Part of the wages for the last thirty days of work before the insolvency proceedings, up to a limit.

If you continue to supply a company in insolvency proceedings, your invoices dating from after the order are claims against the estate and must be paid when they fall due. Earlier invoices are insolvency claims and are paid according to their class. If the later invoices are not paid, you can claim them before the insolvency judge, although you will not be able to apply for attachment of the company's assets to recover them while no composition with creditors (“convenio”) is in effect. When the assets are not enough to pay all the claims against the estate, the law sets a special order among them.

Then, the insolvency claims by class

Debts prior to the insolvency order are classified in the list of creditors and paid in this order:

  • Claims with special priority. These are claims secured on a specific asset, for example by a mortgage or a pledge. So is, among others, the claim under a finance lease over the leased asset. They are paid out of whatever is obtained from that asset. Any part not covered is recognised in the class that corresponds to it, normally as an ordinary claim.
  • Claims with general priority. They are paid out of the rest of the assets, in the order set by law and, within each group, pro rata, that is, in proportion to what is owed to each creditor. They include part of the wages owed to employees, the amounts withheld for tax and Social Security, what is owed to self-employed people working for the company for work done in the previous six months, half of the other debts owed to the tax authorities and Social Security and half of the claim of the creditor who petitioned for the insolvency proceedings.
  • Ordinary claims. These are claims that have no priority and are not subordinated, such as most unsecured debts owed to suppliers and banks. They are paid pro rata, together with the part of the claims with special priority that was not covered by their asset.
  • Subordinated claims. They are only paid once the ordinary claims have been paid in full, which rarely happens. They include, among others, claims lodged late, interest, fines and the claims of persons specially related to the company, such as loans from shareholders with at least 10 % of the capital or claims of the directors.

The class of each claim

The class of each claim is proposed by the insolvency practitioner in the list of creditors. If you disagree with the class given to yours, you can challenge it, which is a separate matter. If the company reaches a composition with its creditors, what each of them receives also depends on what is approved in it.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.