What is the time limit to challenge the list of creditors?

Ten working days, counted from when the report of the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”), with the inventory and the list of creditors, is published in the “Registro Público Concursal”, the public insolvency register. A challenge can be brought by those who are parties to the insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), that is, those who have entered an appearance in them through a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”). There is a simpler step before that. The insolvency practitioner sends out a draft of the list at least ten days before submitting it and corrections can be requested up to three days beforehand. Anyone who does not challenge the list in time can no longer ask later for it to be changed.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Before the list, the draft

The insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”), who is the professional appointed by the judge to run the insolvency proceedings (the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”), prepares an inventory of the assets and a list of creditors with the amount and class of each claim. At least ten days before submitting them to the judge, the practitioner emails the draft to the debtor and to the creditors who lodged their claims and whose address is known, whether or not they are included. That email states the day on which the report will be submitted.

Up to three days before that date, any of them can ask the practitioner, also by email, to correct errors or complete the information. No lawyer or court agent (“procurador”) is needed for this and it is the quickest way to put a mistake right.

Challenging the list before the judge

On the day the report is submitted, the insolvency practitioner emails it, together with the inventory and the list, to the creditors who lodged their claims. The court sends it that same day to the “Registro Público Concursal”, the public insolvency register.

The ten-day time limit runs from when the report is published in that register. They are working days, so days that are non-working for court purposes, such as Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays, do not count. Challenges can be brought by the parties who have entered an appearance in the insolvency proceedings. A creditor who has not yet done so can enter an appearance through a lawyer and a court agent within that time limit and file their challenge at the same time.

A challenge to the list can seek changes such as these:

  • Including a claim that has been left out or excluding one that should not be there.
  • Correcting the amount of a recognised claim.
  • Changing its class, for example from ordinary to priority or from subordinated to ordinary.

The inventory can also be challenged, to have assets included or excluded or their value changed. The challenge is dealt with as an interlocutory application (“incidente concursal”), a short trial within the insolvency proceedings themselves that is decided by the judge.

If no challenge is made in time

Anyone who does not challenge within the time limit cannot later ask for the inventory or the list to be amended, except to appeal against the changes the judge makes when deciding other people's challenges. If a creditor's claim appears as subordinated and the creditor does not challenge this in time, the judge also declares any security the creditor held over the company's assets extinguished.

Once the challenges have been decided, the insolvency practitioner submits the final list. From then on it only changes in specific cases laid down by law, such as claims recognised later by a judgment. In the special procedure for micro-enterprises, the time limits and the way of challenging are different.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.