Who pays the debts of a company in insolvency proceedings?

The company itself pays them, with all its assets and rights and in the order laid down by the “Ley Concursal”, Spain's Insolvency Act. If it is a limited company or a public limited company (“sociedad limitada” or “sociedad anónima”), the shareholders are not, as a general rule, liable for its debts with their personal assets. Nor are the directors, except in specific cases, such as where the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) are classified as culpable and the judge orders them to cover the shortfall. Anyone who guaranteed a debt generally remains liable for it. If the company's assets are not enough and no one else is liable, the creditor does not recover the rest.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The company pays with its own assets

Insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) do not transfer the debts to anyone. The company still owes them and answers for them with its insolvency estate (“masa activa”), that is, with all the assets and rights it had when the insolvency was declared and those it acquires or recovers until the proceedings end, except those that the law declares exempt from attachment.

Those assets are used to pay, as they fall due, the debts that arise during the proceedings, such as the costs of the procedure itself. Earlier creditors are paid according to the class of their claim, which may be a priority claim, an ordinary claim or a subordinated claim. Who is paid first is a separate matter.

How they are paid depends on how the proceedings end. If a composition with creditors (“convenio”) is approved, the company pays what was agreed in it, which may include reductions in the debt, known as write-downs (“quitas”), or deferrals of payment, known as “esperas”. If liquidation is opened, the company's assets are sold and the money is shared out among the creditors.

When others are liable

As a general rule, the shareholders of a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) or a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”) are not personally liable for the company's debts. They risk what they contributed, but not their own assets. Other people may have to pay in these cases:

  • Guarantors. They generally remain liable and the creditor can claim against them without waiting for the proceedings to end. It is advisable not to delay, because the insolvency proceedings interrupt the limitation period as against the company, but not as against them. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
  • Directors or liquidators, if the insolvency is classified as culpable and the judgment orders them to cover, in whole or in part, the shortfall still owed to the creditors, to the extent that their conduct caused or aggravated the insolvency.
  • Directors, for debts that arose when the company was already subject to a legal ground for dissolution, for example because of serious losses, if they did not promptly bring about the dissolution or apply for insolvency proceedings. From the insolvency order until the composition takes effect or, if there is a liquidation, until the proceedings end, the courts do not admit these claims and any already under way are stayed.
  • Partners in firms where they are personally liable for the firm's debts, such as a general partnership (“sociedad colectiva”). During the insolvency proceedings, only the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”) can claim the earlier debts from them.
  • Shareholders of a limited company with capital of less than 3.000 euros. If, when it is liquidated, its assets are not enough to pay the debts, they are liable for the difference between 3.000 euros and the capital they subscribed. Any one of them may have to pay it in full.

What is owed to employees is subject to its own rules, which are a separate matter.

What remains unpaid

If the proceedings end with the sale of all the assets or because they are not enough even to pay the costs of the procedure, nobody else bears what remains unpaid, except those who are liable on one of those grounds. In addition, the judge orders the provisional closure of the company's registry sheet at the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) and, if the proceedings are not reopened within a year, the companies registrar cancels its registration. During that year, any creditor who has not been paid can ask for the proceedings to be reopened if new assets come to light.

If the business belongs to an individual, such as a self-employed person, the position is different. Their debts are not extinguished when the proceedings end and they remain liable for them with their present and future assets, unless they obtain a discharge of unsatisfied liabilities (“exoneración del pasivo insatisfecho”), which is the writing-off of the debts that remain unpaid. Its requirements are a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.