What happens to a finance lease (“leasing”) in insolvency proceedings?
The contract remains in force, because the leasing company cannot terminate it simply because the business goes into insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”). Instalments left unpaid before the insolvency order are, as a general rule, a claim with special priority over the asset. Those falling due afterwards are paid as an expense of the proceedings themselves or are added to that priority claim, depending on what the contract says. If the asset is necessary for the business, the leasing company generally cannot recover it until a composition with creditors (“convenio”) that does not prevent it takes effect or a year passes from the insolvency order without liquidation being opened.
Alburquerque Abogados
The contract continues and what happens to the instalments
A finance lease (“leasing”, also called “arrendamiento financiero”) is the contract under which a financial institution grants the business the use of an asset, such as a machine, a vehicle or an industrial unit, in return for instalments and with a purchase option at the end. Insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) do not bring it to an end. Clauses allowing the leasing company to terminate or amend it merely because of the insolvency proceedings are treated as if they had never been written.
What is owed under the contract is treated differently depending on when it falls due:
- Instalments that fell due and were left unpaid before the insolvency order are an insolvency claim with special priority over the asset, provided the contract was formalised before the insolvency proceedings in compliance with the requirements that the law lays down for it to be effective against third parties. The leasing company is paid ahead of others out of that specific asset.
- How instalments falling due afterwards are treated depends on what the contract says. If the leasing company took on obligations that are still outstanding, such as maintenance or insurance of the asset, the business pays the instalments as they fall due, as an expense of the insolvency proceedings. If the leasing company fully performed its side of the contract on delivering the asset, the outstanding instalments are added to the claim with special priority.
The courts examine the clauses of each contract. The fact that the business continues to use the asset or can buy it at the end is not enough, on its own, to treat the instalments as an expense of the proceedings. An operating lease (“renting”), which is a form of hire and not a way of financing the purchase of the asset, does not carry this priority and is partly governed by other rules, which are a separate matter.
If the leasing company wants to recover the asset
If the contract is registered in the “Registro de Bienes Muebles”, the register of movable property, or in the Land Registry (“Registro de la Propiedad”), or was signed before a notary, as a public deed or as a notarised commercial contract (“póliza”), an action to recover the asset follows the same rules as the enforcement of a mortgage or a pledge in insolvency proceedings:
- If the asset is necessary for the business to continue, the leasing company cannot bring or pursue that action until a composition with creditors (“convenio”) that does not prevent it takes effect or a year passes from the insolvency order without liquidation being opened.
- If it is not necessary, the leasing company can recover it once the insolvency judge so declares, at its request and after hearing the insolvency practitioner (“administración concursal”).
If the contract still has obligations pending for both parties and the business stops paying the instalments falling due during the proceedings, the leasing company can ask the insolvency judge to terminate it. The business, or the insolvency practitioner if acting in its place, can object and ask for the contract to be kept in force, offering to pay what is owed out of the insolvency estate within the three months following the judgment. The judge decides. The business or the insolvency practitioner, as the case may be, can also ask the judge to terminate the contract even if there has been no breach, if that is in the interest of the insolvency proceedings. Any compensation then due to the leasing company is recognised as an insolvency claim.
What to do
If you are the business in insolvency proceedings, review as soon as possible which leased assets you need to keep operating. Which contracts it is worth keeping and which should be terminated is decided together with the insolvency practitioner. For those that are kept, the instalments due must continue to be paid.
If you are the leasing company, lodge your claim with the insolvency practitioner within one month of the publication of the insolvency proceedings in the “BOE”, Spain's Official State Gazette, including everything owed to you and the special priority to which you are entitled. If you consider that the later instalments should be paid as an expense of the proceedings, say so from the outset.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.