Who pays the insolvency practitioner?
The insolvency practitioner is paid out of the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) themselves, that is, out of the debtor's assets, which the law calls the insolvency estate (“masa activa”). Neither the court nor, as a general rule, the creditors pay them. Their remuneration is a claim against the estate, one of the debts that arise from the proceedings themselves and are paid when they fall due, ahead of the debts that predate the insolvency order. If the assets are not enough to pay all those debts, the law sets an order of payment and the insolvency practitioner may go without part of their remuneration. The exception is insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”), in which the creditors who ask for an insolvency practitioner to be appointed pay.
Alburquerque Abogados
Paid out of the debtor's assets
The law gives the insolvency practitioner the right to remuneration paid out of the insolvency estate, which is the whole of the debtor's assets and rights subject to the insolvency proceedings. The amount is set by the judge under the official scale of fees and comes out of those assets, whether the debtor in insolvency proceedings is a company, a self-employed person (“autónomo”) or a private individual.
That remuneration is a claim against the estate. That is the name given, in general, to the debts arising from the proceedings themselves or after the insolvency order, such as the costs of the proceedings. As a general rule they are paid when they fall due, without waiting for the end of the proceedings. They are also paid before anything is shared out among the creditors whose claims predate the insolvency proceedings. The insolvency practitioner's payment dates are set by the judge in the same order that fixes their remuneration.
No one else can top up what they receive. The insolvency practitioner may not accept any payment, in cash or in kind, from the debtor, the creditors or third parties over and above what the judge sets.
If the assets are not enough
When the insolvency practitioner finds that the assets are not enough, or are unlikely to be enough, to pay all the claims against the estate, they must notify the judge. From then on, the claims essential for liquidating the assets are paid first. The law treats the insolvency practitioner's remuneration during the liquidation stage as essential in all cases. If not even those claims can be paid in full, they are paid pro rata, that is, in proportion to their amount.
The other claims against the estate are paid afterwards, in the order set by law. In that order, the insolvency practitioner's remuneration for the stages before the liquidation ranks behind other claims that the law puts ahead of it. That is why the insolvency practitioner may end up not receiving everything the judge had awarded them.
When the creditors pay
In insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets, which are, broadly speaking, those of a debtor without enough assets even to pay the costs of the proceedings themselves, the judge declares the insolvency without appointing an insolvency practitioner. Creditors representing at least 5 % of the debts can ask, within fifteen days of the official notice being published, for one to be appointed to report within a month on whether there are detrimental transactions that could be set aside, claims against the directors or grounds for classifying the insolvency as culpable.
If they do so, the judge sets the remuneration for that report in the same order that makes the appointment, to be paid by the creditors who requested it. Outside that case, a creditor's taking part in the insolvency proceedings, or having petitioned for them, does not oblige that creditor to pay the insolvency practitioner.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.