What is meant by insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”)?
These are insolvency proceedings concerning a debtor who has no assets, or whose assets are not even enough to pay the costs of the proceedings themselves. The estate (“masa”) is the set of the debtor's assets and rights out of which the creditors are paid. When the petition shows that there is none, the judge makes the insolvency order without appointing an insolvency practitioner and gives creditors representing at least 5 % of the debts fifteen days to ask for one to be appointed, at their own expense. If nobody asks, the judge closes the proceedings. If the debtor is an individual, before that they can ask for the debts left unpaid to be written off.
Alburquerque Abogados
When there is no estate
Spain's Insolvency Act (“Ley Concursal”) considers that there is no estate (“masa”) when one of the following situations arises, examined in this order:
- The debtor has no assets or rights that can be attached.
- What it would cost to sell the assets is clearly disproportionate to what they would foreseeably fetch.
- The unencumbered assets are worth less than the foreseeable cost of the proceedings.
- The charges on the assets, such as a mortgage, exceed their market value.
The judge assesses this on the basis of the insolvency petition and the accompanying documents, in which the debtor must describe its assets, its charges and its debts.
How it is dealt with
The judge makes the insolvency order, stating the debts shown by the documents and without ruling on anything else. The judge neither appoints an insolvency practitioner, who is the professional the judge designates to act in the insolvency proceedings, nor opens the ordinary stages of the proceedings. The order is published in Spain's Official State Gazette (the “Boletín Oficial del Estado”) and in the public insolvency register (the “Registro Público Concursal”), together with a call to creditors.
Creditors representing, alone or together, at least 5 % of the debts can ask, within the fifteen days following publication, for an insolvency practitioner to be appointed. The practitioner's task is to report within a month on whether there are signs that the debtor carried out acts detrimental to creditors that can be undone, that the company's directors can be held liable for the harm they caused it or that the insolvency may be culpable, that is, that it was caused or aggravated through wilful misconduct or gross negligence. The practitioner's remuneration is paid by the creditors who asked for the appointment.
If the report finds such signs, the judge completes the insolvency order and opens the liquidation of the assets. The proceedings then continue along the ordinary route.
How it ends
If nobody asks for an insolvency practitioner, or if the practitioner's report finds no such signs, the judge closes the proceedings for lack of assets.
If the debtor is a company, the decision closing the proceedings orders the provisional closure of its registry sheet at the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). If no assets come to light within a year that would allow the proceedings to be reopened, the companies registrar cancels the company's registration. Closing the proceedings does not extinguish the company's debts.
If the debtor is an individual, they can apply for the discharge of unsatisfied liabilities, which is the writing off of the debts left unpaid, if they meet the legal requirements. They have ten days to do so from the end of the creditors' time limit without anyone asking for an insolvency practitioner, or from the filing by the practitioner of a report finding no such signs. If nobody objects, the judge grants the discharge in the same decision that closes the proceedings.
Micro-enterprises, which are business owners and companies with fewer than ten employees and small turnover or debt figures, are subject by law to their own special procedure, which is another matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.