What happens if the restructuring plan is not approved?

It depends on who does not approve it. If some classes of creditors reject it, the judge can still confirm it and impose it on those that voted against, provided that it has been approved by the classes the law requires. If the plan needs a resolution of the general meeting and the shareholders reject it, it can go ahead without them only when the company is in actual or imminent insolvency and is not a small business. If the plan cannot be confirmed, the debts remain as they were and, if the company cannot pay them, its directors must petition for insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”).

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

If some classes of creditors vote against

Each class approves the plan when creditors holding more than two thirds of the amount of its claims vote in favour, or three quarters if they are claims with security in rem. If a class falls short, the judge can still confirm the plan if it has been approved by:

  • A simple majority of the classes, provided that at least one of them is made up of claims that would have priority in insolvency proceedings, such as those secured by a mortgage or other security in rem.
  • Failing that, at least one class that would reasonably have received something if the business were valued as a going concern. This requires a report from the restructuring expert on that value.

To impose the plan on a class that has voted against it, a restructuring expert must be appointed. Small businesses, which are those with no more than forty-nine employees and an annual turnover or balance sheet of no more than ten million euros that are not part of a group required to consolidate its accounts, also have a rule of their own. Their plan can be confirmed even if not all the classes approve it, provided that the classes that voted against receive more favourable treatment than any lower-ranking class.

Creditors in the classes that voted against can then challenge the court confirmation on grounds of their own, for example if their class receives worse treatment than another of the same rank or if it is paid less than it is owed while a lower-ranking class or the shareholders keep something.

If the shareholders or the debtor reject it

When the plan includes measures that need a resolution of the general meeting, such as a capital increase or the conversion of debt into quotas (“participaciones”), rejection by the shareholders has different consequences depending on the company's situation:

  • Where there is a likelihood of insolvency, the plan cannot be confirmed without that resolution.
  • In actual or imminent insolvency, it can be confirmed even if the shareholders do not approve it. In addition, the shareholders then have no pre-emption right to subscribe for the new shares or quotas, which may lead to the creditors taking control of the company.

Rejection always prevents court confirmation in two cases. The first is where the debtor is an individual and does not approve the plan. The second is where it is a small business, because the law then requires the approval of the debtor and, where applicable, of its shareholders.

If the plan does not go ahead

If none of these approvals is obtained, the plan cannot be confirmed and does not bind the creditors who did not accept it. The debts remain on their original terms and the creditors can claim them.

If the company had notified the court of the opening of negotiations with its creditors, which is known as the pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”), the protection against enforcement proceedings ends when its effects run out. If by then it has not reached a plan and is in actual insolvency, it must petition for insolvency proceedings within the following month. If there was no such notice, its directors must petition within two months of the date on which they knew or should have known of the insolvency. How long the effects of the pre-insolvency stage last is a separate matter.

Court confirmation can also fall away later. If the “Audiencia Provincial”, the provincial appeal court, upholds a challenge because the majorities were not reached or because the classes were wrongly formed, the entire plan ceases to have effect.

Other ways out remain, such as negotiating a different plan, selling the business or proposing a composition with creditors (“convenio”) within the insolvency proceedings, which are a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.