What happens after insolvency proceedings?
It depends on how the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) end. If they are closed because a composition with creditors (“convenio”) has been fulfilled or because everything has been paid, the debtor carries on with its business free of the restrictions of the insolvency proceedings. If they are closed after the assets have been liquidated or because the assets were not even enough to pay the costs of the proceedings themselves, the judge orders the provisional closure of the debtor company's registry sheet at the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) and, if the proceedings are not reopened within a year, the registrar cancels its registration. An individual, on the other hand, still owes what was not paid and their creditors can once again seize their assets, unless the individual obtains forgiveness of those debts through the second chance procedure (“segunda oportunidad”).
Alburquerque Abogados
What ends when the proceedings are closed
When the judge declares the insolvency proceedings closed, the restrictions on the debtor's power to manage and dispose of its assets end, except for those imposed by any judgment that has classified the insolvency as culpable. The insolvency practitioner, who must first have accounted for their management, also leaves office. The judge orders the case file to be archived, although the culpability section (“sección de calificación”), which decides whether the insolvency is culpable, may continue.
If the proceedings ended because the composition was fulfilled, the agreed reductions are final and the creditors can no longer claim the forgiven part from the debtor.
If the debtor is a company
When a company's insolvency proceedings are closed because its assets have been liquidated or because they were not enough to pay the costs of the proceedings themselves, the judge orders the provisional closure of its registry sheet at the Companies Registry. If a year passes without the proceedings being reopened, the registrar cancels its registration and the sheet is closed for good. The company thus ceases to appear in the Registry.
The debts left unpaid do not disappear on their own, but the company no longer has any assets with which to pay them. If new assets come to light later, any creditor who has not been paid can apply, within a year of the closure, for the insolvency proceedings to be reopened in order to liquidate them. In the application, the creditor must specify the particular actions to be brought to recover assets or the facts that could lead to the insolvency being classified as culpable, unless it has already been classified as such.
Whether the creditors can claim the shortfall from the directors or the shareholders is a separate matter.
If the debtor is an individual
When the insolvency proceedings of an individual, whether a self-employed person (“autónomo”) or a private individual, end through liquidation or for lack of assets, the debtor remains liable for the debts that were not paid. The exception is where the debtor obtains a discharge of unsatisfied liabilities (“exoneración del pasivo insatisfecho”), which is the forgiveness of the debts that remain unpaid and is known as the second chance. Its requirements are a separate matter.
If the debtor does not obtain that forgiveness, the creditors can once again claim against the debtor and seize the debtor's assets individually, as long as the insolvency proceedings are not reopened and no new ones are declared. For this purpose, the inclusion of their claims in the final list of creditors counts as a final judgment ordering payment, so they can apply directly for enforcement.
An individual's insolvency proceedings can only be reopened within five years of their closure. After that period, new insolvency proceedings are treated as separate proceedings.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.