What are the consequences of a culpable insolvency?
They are set by the classification judgment, which names the persons affected by the classification, usually the company's directors, as well as any accessories. The persons affected are disqualified for a period of two to fifteen years from managing other people's assets and from representing anyone. Those affected and accessories also lose any claims they had in the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) and may be ordered to return what they obtained improperly and to compensate for the damage caused. If the liquidation stage has been opened, the judge can also order the directors, liquidators or general managers affected to cover with their own assets, in whole or in part, whatever is lacking to pay the creditors. Nor can anyone declared a person affected obtain a discharge of their own debts under the second-chance procedure (“segunda oportunidad”) if they apply for it within the following ten years, unless they have first paid their liability in full.
Alburquerque Abogados
What the judgment decides
If the judge classifies the insolvency as culpable, the judgment explains why and also contains the following rulings:
- Who the persons affected are and, where applicable, the accessories. In a company, the persons affected may be its directors or liquidators, whether formally appointed or de facto, its general managers and anyone who held those posts in the two years before the insolvency order.
- The disqualification of the persons affected, which is explained below.
- The loss of any rights that those affected and accessories had as creditors in the insolvency proceedings, such as the claim for a loan the director made to the company.
- An order to return any assets or rights they obtained improperly from the debtor's property or received from the insolvency estate.
- An order to pay damages for the harm caused. The judge decides whether each person ordered to pay is liable for the full compensation or only for their share.
If the classification takes place once the liquidation stage has been opened, the judge can add an order to cover the shortfall (“condena a cubrir el déficit”), which is the difference between the value of the assets and the total of the recognised claims. It applies only to the directors, liquidators and general managers affected, to the extent that their conduct generated or aggravated the insolvency. Its requirements are another matter.
Disqualification
Disqualification prevents the person from managing other people's assets and from representing anyone for the period set by the judgment, between two and fifteen years. The judge sets the length according to the seriousness of the facts, the harm caused to the insolvency estate and any disqualifications the same person has from other culpable insolvencies. If the person is disqualified in several insolvency proceedings, the periods are added together.
While it lasts, the disqualified person cannot carry on business or hold office in, or have any direct, administrative or financial involvement in, commercial companies. Once the judgment is final, disqualified directors and liquidators automatically cease to hold office in the insolvent company. The disqualification is notified to the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) and to the “Registro de la Propiedad”, the Land Registry. Only exceptionally, if there is a composition with creditors (“convenio”) and the insolvency practitioner asked for it, can the judgment allow the disqualified person to remain at the head of the business while the composition is being performed.
Other consequences
A person declared to be affected cannot obtain the discharge of unsatisfied liabilities, which is the forgiveness of one's own debts known as the second chance, if they apply for it within the following ten years, unless they have first paid their liability in full. If the culpable insolvency is that of an individual, that classification in principle prevents them from obtaining the forgiveness of their debts. Where the only cause was failing to petition for insolvency proceedings in time, the judge can take into account the circumstances of the delay.
The classification is not binding on the criminal courts. If the classification reports show that the facts may amount to a criminal offence, the insolvency judge informs the Public Prosecutor's Office (“Ministerio Fiscal”). The criminal side is another matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.