What is the difference between a joint venture and a UTE?

A UTE, or temporary business association (“unión temporal de empresas”), is an arrangement regulated by law so that several companies can work together on a specific construction project, service or supply without creating a new legal person. The term joint venture, by contrast, is a generic name for any collaboration between companies on a common project, which can be organised through a contract or by setting up a company. A UTE is therefore one form of joint venture, but not the only one. The difference that matters most is liability, because in a UTE the companies have unlimited joint and several liability to third parties, whereas in a joint venture company each shareholder risks, in principle, only what it contributes.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

What a UTE is

The law defines the UTE, or temporary business association (“unión temporal de empresas”), as a system of collaboration between businesses for developing or carrying out a construction project, a service or a supply. Its features are as follows:

  • It has no legal personality. The companies act together, but the UTE is not a company separate from them.
  • It lasts as long as the construction project, service or supply that justifies it.
  • It acts through a single manager, holding powers of attorney from all the companies that form it.
  • The companies have unlimited joint and several liability to third parties for the acts and transactions carried out for their common benefit. In other words, a creditor can claim the whole amount from any one of them, which can then claim from the others the share that corresponds to them.

It is very common in public procurement. Several companies can bid jointly in a tender, undertaking to form the UTE if they win. They only have to formalise it in a public deed once the contract is awarded to them and they are jointly and severally bound to the public authority. Its own tax regime, which requires other conditions to be met, is a separate matter.

What a joint venture is

Joint venture is not a legal form but an English expression for any common project of several independent companies that share its control, its risks and its results. It can be organised in several ways:

  • Through a collaboration agreement between the companies, without creating anything new.
  • Through a UTE, when the venture is a specific construction project, service or supply.
  • Through a joint venture company, usually a limited company (“sociedad limitada”), in which the companies are shareholders.
  • Through an economic interest grouping (“agrupación de interés económico”, AIE), which has legal personality but can only carry on an activity ancillary to that of its members, who are personally liable, jointly and severally, for its debts if the grouping does not pay them.

The differences that matter

The form of joint venture that differs most from the UTE is the joint venture company. Compared side by side, the differences are as follows:

  • Legal personality. The UTE does not have it. The joint venture company has it from its registration with the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”), so it enters into contracts and is liable in its own name.
  • Liability. In the UTE all the companies have unlimited joint and several liability for the common debts. In the joint venture company the shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts, unless they guarantee them.
  • Purpose and duration. The UTE is limited to a construction project, a service or a supply and lasts as long as these do. The joint venture company can engage in any lawful activity and is not tied to a specific project, so it lasts as long as its shareholders wish.
  • Form. The UTE is normally formalised in a public deed setting out its terms. The company also requires articles of association, capital, registration with the Companies Registry and the filing of its accounts every year.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.