What is the difference between a partial demerger and a hive-down?
In both, a company transfers to another company, new or already existing, one or more parts of its assets and liabilities that form an economic unit, while it continues to exist with the rest. The difference lies in who receives in return the quotas (“participaciones”) or shares of the company that takes that part. In a partial demerger they go to the shareholders, who thereby also become shareholders of the other company, while the company being divided reduces its capital. In a hive-down (“segregación”) they go to the company itself, which becomes a shareholder of the other. Its shareholders keep what they had and the company now holds, in place of what it transferred, a stake in the other.
Alburquerque Abogados
What they have in common
Both are forms of demerger governed by Royal Decree-Law 5/2023 (the “Real Decreto-ley”). In both, what is transferred must form an economic unit, that is, a set of assets and resources capable of operating on its own, such as a business, an establishment or an activity. It passes en bloc, by universal succession, with its assets, its debts and its contracts.
The procedure is the same. The directors draw up draft terms of demerger, which are made public one month before the general meeting unless all the shareholders approve the transaction at a universal meeting (“junta universal”). In a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) the general meeting approves it by at least two thirds of the votes attaching to all the quotas (“participaciones”). The deed is then executed and registered with the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”).
They also protect creditors in the same way. If the company that has to pay a debt incurred before the draft terms, which had not yet fallen due when they were published, does not pay it, the other companies involved are liable for it, each up to the value of what it received or retained, net of debts. This liability becomes time-barred after five years.
How they differ
Apart from who receives the quotas, the two transactions differ in the following respects:
- The capital of the transferring company. In a partial demerger it is reduced to the extent necessary, because part of the value goes out to the shareholders. In a hive-down (“segregación”) the law does not require it to be reduced, because the company replaces what it transfers with the quotas it receives.
- The resulting structure. When the part transferred goes to a new company, after a partial demerger with a proportional allocation the two companies end up in the hands of the same shareholders, as sister companies. After a hive-down, by contrast, the original company sits above the new one as its parent company and the two form a group.
- The shareholders' consent. In a partial demerger, if any shareholder does not receive quotas in the company taking the part transferred, their individual consent is needed. In a hive-down the question does not arise, because the shareholders receive nothing.
- The formalities the law waives. If the partial demerger is in favour of new companies and the quotas are allocated in proportion to what each shareholder held, there is no need for the directors' report, the independent experts' report or the demerger balance sheet. In a hive-down in favour of a new company or of a wholly owned subsidiary, the directors' report is not needed. An expert's report is only required, where the recipient is a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”), to check that what is contributed covers its capital.
When each one is used
A partial demerger is the right fit when the aim is for the shareholders to hold directly the part that leaves. This is the case for someone who wants the properties in a company separate from the business activity, in the hands of the same shareholders, or for shareholders who are parting ways and dividing the businesses between them.
A hive-down is the right fit when the company wants to keep that part under its control, for example to prepare for its sale or for a new shareholder to come into it without affecting the rest, or to organise its activities as a group. The tax consequences of each are a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.