What is the difference between a situation of risk and abandonment (“desamparo”)?

The difference lies in how serious the situation is and whether the child can go on living with their family. In a situation of risk, the child's development or well-being is being harmed, but there is no need to remove them from their family and social services work with the parents to put the situation right. Where there is abandonment (“desamparo”), the situation is so serious that the child's protection requires removing them from the family. The Generalitat de Catalunya (the Catalan government) then assumes guardianship of the child and parental authority (“potestad parental”) is suspended. A risk that is not remedied can end in abandonment.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The situation of risk

Catalan law speaks of risk when the child's development or well-being is limited or harmed by personal, social or family circumstances, without it being necessary to remove them from their family in order to protect them. Examples are a lack of attention that causes the child minor harm, serious difficulties on the parents' part in caring for the child, truancy or dropping out of school, physical or emotional punishment that harms the child's development without amounting to a serious incident or to habitual violence and open, chronic conflict between the parents in which their own needs come before the child's.

The primary social services step in first, assessing the situation, seeking the parents' cooperation and assigning a key worker to the case. They can offer guidance and assistance to the family, help with schooling, home help or the child's attendance at a day centre. If the risk is serious and is not reduced, they refer the case to the specialised children's services, which draw up a socio-educational commitment (“compromiso socioeducativo”) with the parents after hearing the adolescent, or the child if they have sufficient understanding.

Throughout that time the child remains at home and the parents retain parental authority.

Abandonment

There is abandonment when the child lacks the basic necessities for their all-round development or suffers ill-treatment or abuse and their protection requires removing them from their family. It is declared by the Generalitat, which assumes guardianship of the child. Parental authority is suspended while the measure lasts and the child goes to live with another family, with relatives or in a residential centre. The parents remain obliged to provide maintenance for the child.

The law itself provides for moving from one situation to the other. If the parents do not cooperate and the child remains in danger, the specialised services can propose that a file be opened to declare abandonment. The accumulation of situations of risk that are not remedied is also one of the grounds for abandonment.

In most of the rest of Spain

The “Ley Orgánica de Protección Jurídica del Menor”, Spain's law on the legal protection of minors, follows the same approach. In a situation of risk the child suffers harm that does not reach the seriousness of abandonment and the public authorities intervene without removing the child from their family, through a social and educational intervention plan that the parents sign and in which the child is consulted if sufficiently mature and, in any event, from the age of twelve. A situation of risk can be declared by a reasoned administrative decision, which can be challenged in court.

Where there is abandonment, the “Entidad Pública”, which is the child protection body of each autonomous community, assumes guardianship of the child by operation of law and parental authority (“patria potestad”) is suspended.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.