When does the obligation to provide maintenance end?
The obligation ends when the person receiving maintenance no longer needs it, when the person providing it can no longer do so without neglecting their own needs and when either of them dies. It also ends if the person receiving it falls within one of the grounds for disinheritance, such as seriously ill-treating the person who helps them. In Catalonia it is also extinguished by divorce or annulment of the marriage, in the case of maintenance between spouses, or when the father or mother receiving it from a child was deprived of parental authority over that child. If it was set by a judge, unless the person receiving it dies, it is not enough to stop paying and the judge must be asked to declare the obligation extinguished.
Alburquerque Abogados
The grounds in Catalonia
The “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, lists the following grounds on which the obligation is extinguished:
- The death of the person receiving maintenance or of the person providing it.
- Divorce and a declaration of nullity of the marriage, in the case of maintenance between spouses.
- A reduction in the income or assets of the person providing it, when they can no longer comply without neglecting their own needs and those of the relatives who have priority to receive maintenance from them.
- An improvement in the situation of the person receiving it, when they no longer need it.
- The person receiving it falls within a ground for disinheritance, even if they have no right to the forced share (“legítima”) in the estate of the person providing the maintenance. For example, having refused them maintenance when obliged to provide it, having seriously ill-treated them or having no family relationship with them, manifestly and continuously, for a reason attributable solely to the recipient.
- Deprivation of parental authority over the child who is obliged to pay, when the person receiving maintenance is the father or mother.
The ground for disinheritance ceases to have effect if the person providing maintenance forgives the person receiving it or if they are reconciled. In addition, the law only recognises the right to maintenance as long as the need is not due to a cause attributable to the person claiming it.
In most of the rest of Spain
The Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) says that the obligation ends on the death of the person providing maintenance, even if they were paying it under a final judgment. It also lists the following grounds:
- The death of the person receiving it.
- A reduction in the wealth of the person providing it to the point where they cannot pay it without neglecting their own needs and those of their family.
- The person receiving it can practise a trade, a profession or a business, or has become better off, so that they no longer need it to live on.
- The person receiving it has committed one of the wrongs that allow disinheritance, whether or not they are a forced heir.
- The person receiving it is a descendant of the person providing it and their need stems from their own misconduct or lack of application to work, for as long as that cause lasts.
If maintenance was set by a judge
If the amount was set in a judgment or in an agreement approved by the judge, the person paying should not stop doing so on their own initiative, even if they believe that one of these grounds applies, unless the person receiving it has died. The prudent course is to ask the judge to declare the obligation extinguished. Before bringing the claim, the law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement, for example through negotiation or mediation. Until the matter is decided, any amounts left unpaid can be claimed.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.