Can you sue a sibling for not looking after your parents?

Not for failing to look after them, because the law does not oblige children to care for their parents personally. What does exist is the maintenance obligation of all the children, in proportion to their means, when the father or mother cannot support themselves. That maintenance is claimed by the father or mother themselves or by whoever represents them, not by a sibling in their own name. If you have paid your sibling's share, recovering it is not always possible and depends, among other things, on whether your father or mother had previously claimed maintenance. Before suing, the law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Who can claim maintenance

In Catalonia, maintenance can only be claimed by the person who needs it or, where appropriate, their legal representative, as well as by the public or private institution that has taken them in. A sibling cannot claim it in their own name, because the right belongs to the father or mother.

If your father or mother is able to decide, they are the one who must claim it, even if you help them. If they can no longer do so, someone with powers to represent them will have to act for them, such as an attorney holding a sufficient preventive power of attorney (“poder preventivo”) or the person to whom the judge has granted powers of representation. The claim is brought against the children who are obliged to pay. The judge divides the obligation in proportion to each one's resources and capacity to pay.

If you have paid on your sibling's behalf

The “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, allows a person who provides maintenance in place of the person obliged to claim from them the payments for the current year and the previous year, with statutory interest, unless it is clear that they did so without expecting to be repaid. Whether that rule helps a child who has paid a sibling's share is unclear, especially if the father or mother had not previously claimed maintenance from that sibling, because maintenance is only owed from the time it is claimed. That is why it is advisable for the father or mother themselves, or whoever represents them, to claim maintenance from all the children as soon as possible. It is also advisable to put in writing that you expect to be repaid.

If the judge imposes the whole payment on just one of the children, that child can also claim from each of the others their share, with statutory interest.

Before bringing any of these claims, the law generally requires recourse to some method of trying to reach an agreement, such as negotiation between lawyers, mediation or a confidential binding offer.

In most of the rest of Spain

The Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) recognises the right to maintenance of anyone who needs it and divides its payment among those obliged in proportion to their respective wealth. When the judge provisionally orders just one of them to pay because of urgent need, that person can claim from the others the share that corresponds to them. If a sibling pays on their own initiative, for example for the care home, without the father or mother having previously claimed maintenance from the others, the “Tribunal Supremo”, Spain's Supreme Court, has ruled that they cannot later ask the others for their share.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.