What is a non-compete covenant in the sale of a business?
It is the undertaking given by the seller of a business not to open the same kind of business or work for the competition for a specified period and within a specified area. Its purpose is to protect what the buyer pays for the customer base and the reputation of the business, which would lose much of their value if the seller could take the customers away the next day. It is valid if it is limited to what is necessary to protect that value. As a benchmark, the competition authorities generally accept up to three years if the sale includes the customer base and the know-how of the business. If it includes only the customer base, they accept up to two.
Alburquerque Abogados
What it is for
Someone who buys a business pays not only for its assets but also for its customer base and its reputation, which is known as goodwill. If the seller could open the same kind of business in the same area the next day, many customers would follow. The covenant prevents this for the agreed period and is usually accompanied by other undertakings from the seller:
- Not to solicit the customers or suppliers of the business sold.
- Not to use or disclose the confidential information of the business.
It usually extends to the companies the seller controls, so that it cannot be circumvented through them. If the seller stays on in the business as an employee, the non-compete covenant under the employment contract is another matter.
The limits of the covenant
The covenant restricts the seller's freedom to compete, so its validity depends on its being confined to what is necessary to protect what has been sold. The European Commission and the “Comisión Nacional de los Mercados y la Competencia”, Spain's markets and competition regulator, assess it using these criteria:
- Duration. Up to three years is considered justified if the sale includes the customer base and the know-how of the business. If it includes only the customer base, up to two.
- Area. It may only cover the area in which the seller's products or services were offered before the sale.
- Activity. It may only relate to the products and services of the business sold.
Nor should it prevent the seller from buying shares in a competitor purely as an investment, without taking part in its management. Those criteria were set for the transactions those authorities review, but they are also the safest benchmark in the sale of a small business. A covenant that goes beyond them runs the risk of the seller challenging its validity and of its not being enforceable, at least as regards the excess.
If the seller breaches it
The buyer can require the seller to stop the activity and claim damages for the loss caused, which is not always easy to prove. That is why it is advisable to set a penalty in the contract, that is, an amount the seller will pay in the event of breach, without any need to prove the loss. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
If the contract says nothing, the buyer's protection is much weaker. The buyer would have to rely on the duty to perform contracts in good faith or on the rules on unfair competition, which only cover specific conduct, such as using the business's trade secrets or deceiving customers.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.