What is the difference between an SL and a holding company?

They are not two things of the same kind. A limited company (“sociedad limitada”), or SL, is a legal form of company, whereas the name holding company is given to a company whose main activity is owning stakes in other companies and running them. That is why a holding company can be an SL, which is the most common case among small and medium-sized businesses. What distinguishes a holding company from an SL that runs a business is its role within the group, not the rules that apply to it, which are the same.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

What each one is

The Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) regulates three forms of capital company, which are the limited company (“sociedad limitada”), the public limited company (“sociedad anónima”) and the partnership limited by shares. The SL is the most widely used. Its capital is divided into quotas (“participaciones”) and its shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts.

The law does not regulate the holding company as a type of company. People speak of a holding company when one company, known as the parent company, controls other companies, its subsidiaries, because it holds stakes in them. The law refers to that set as a group of companies and to the parent company as the dominant company (“sociedad dominante”). There is control, for example, when one company holds the majority of the votes in another or can appoint the majority of its directors.

What changes in practice

A holding company set up as an SL is subject to the same rules as any other SL. The differences lie in what it does and in its position within the group:

  • The corporate purpose. Its articles of association include among its activities the holding and management of shareholdings in other companies, on its own or together with other activities.
  • The activity. An operating SL buys, sells, enters into contracts and has employees. The holding company usually confines itself to being a shareholder of its subsidiaries, deciding at their general meetings and, sometimes, providing them with shared services.
  • The accounts. In addition to its own, the holding company must draw up the group's consolidated accounts when the group exceeds certain size thresholds.
  • Wholly owned subsidiaries. If the holding company is their sole shareholder, each subsidiary is a single-member company and must state this in a deed and register it with the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). If six months pass without its being registered, the holding company is liable with its own assets for the debts the subsidiary incurs from the time it became single-member until the situation is registered.

What does not change

Being a holding company does not change liability. The holding company, like any shareholder, is not liable for the debts of its subsidiaries, unless it guarantees them, in the case of the single-member subsidiary explained above or in exceptional cases of abuse. Its own shareholders are not liable for the holding company's debts either.

It is incorporated in the same way as any SL, before a notary and with registration in the Companies Registry. It has the same bodies, namely the general meeting and the directors. It keeps its books and files its annual accounts like any other SL. The tax advantages often attributed to holding companies depend on requirements of their own and are a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.