When is it advisable to set up a holding company?

It usually makes sense when a person, a family or a group of shareholders has, or is going to have, several companies or businesses and wants to run them from a single company, which is what is known as a holding company. It makes it possible to separate the risks of each business, to arrange the entry of new shareholders or the sale of one part without affecting the rest and to prepare for succession in a family business. With a single small business it is rarely worthwhile, because it adds another company with its own accounting, annual accounts and costs. The tax reasons, which often weigh heavily in the decision, are a separate matter.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The situations in which it is usually recommended

A holding company is not a distinct type of company but a way of organising several. One company, usually a limited company (“sociedad limitada”), holds the quotas (“participaciones”) of the others and runs them as their shareholder. These are the situations in which it is most often used:

  • Several different businesses. Each activity sits in its own company, with its own assets and debts. That way the problems of one do not, in principle, drag down the others.
  • Assets kept separate from the business. Properties or other valuable assets are held in a company other than the one that deals with customers and suppliers, which is the one that bears the business risk.
  • Different shareholders in each business. An investor or a manager can be brought into just one of the companies, or that company can be sold, without affecting the others.
  • Succession in a family business. The heirs receive quotas in the holding company rather than in each company, which helps to keep the group together. The family's rules are set out in the articles of association and in the shareholders' agreement of the holding company.
  • Unified management of the group. Important decisions are taken in a single company, which votes at the general meetings of the others and can provide them with shared services, such as accounting or cash management.

What a holding company does not do

Each company is liable for its own debts and the holding company, like any shareholder, is not liable for those of its subsidiaries. That separation is largely lost when the holding company or its owners guarantee the subsidiaries' loans, something banks frequently ask for. In addition, the courts can disregard the separation between companies when it is used to harm creditors, although this is an exceptional remedy that requires the abuse to be proved. The separation also fails if the holding company is the sole shareholder of a subsidiary and that situation is not registered with the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). Once six months have passed without it being registered, the holding company is liable for the debts the subsidiary incurs from the time it became a single-member company until the situation is registered.

Nor does it serve to shield assets from debts that already exist. Moving assets from a company with debts to another company in the group so that its creditors are not paid can be set aside and can make the directors liable.

What it costs to maintain

A holding company is one more company, with its own obligations:

  • Incorporating it before a notary and registering it with the Companies Registry, paying the official fees of both.
  • Keeping its books, approving its annual accounts and filing them every year with the Companies Registry.
  • Also drawing up the group's consolidated accounts when the group exceeds certain size thresholds. In that case they must be audited.

It is therefore worth assessing whether the advantages outweigh those costs and the greater complexity of decision-making at two levels, that of the holding company and that of each subsidiary.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.