How to plan succession in a family business?
It is necessary to decide in good time who will own the business, who will run it and how to compensate the family members who do not continue in it. The estate is arranged in a will or, in Catalonia, also in a succession agreement, which is an agreement signed before a notary with the person who is to succeed. Catalan law makes this easier, because the forced share (“legítima”), which is the minimum part of the estate that the law reserves for children, is only one quarter of the estate and can be paid in cash. The rules of the company are adjusted in the articles of association and in a shareholders' agreement or a family protocol. If nothing is provided for, everyone who inherits the quotas (“participaciones”) becomes a shareholder.
Alburquerque Abogados
What needs to be decided
It helps to separate three decisions. The first is ownership, that is, who will receive the quotas (“participaciones”), whether one child, several or all of them. The second is management, which may fall to a family member or to a professional from outside the family even if the ownership is divided. The third is how those who do not receive the business are compensated and what happens to the spouse, for example through other assets, cash or the usufruct of the quotas, which gives the right to receive their dividends.
The instruments for arranging the estate in Catalonia
If the estate is governed by Catalan law, which depends mainly on the businessperson's “vecindad civil”, that is, the regional civil-law status determining which civil law applies to them, there are these instruments:
- The will. It allows the quotas to be left to whoever is to carry on the business. The other children keep their forced share. That of all the children together, including the one who carries on, is one quarter of the value of the estate, with gifts made in the last ten years generally added in. The heir can pay it with assets from the estate or in cash, even if there is none in the estate.
- The succession agreement. It is signed in a deed with the child or other family member who is to succeed. It can appoint them heir or allocate the quotas to them. It can state that its purpose is the maintenance and continuity of the family business and impose obligations on the recipient. Unlike a will, the person who makes it cannot change it by their own will alone, except in the cases provided for by law or in the agreement itself, such as breach of those obligations.
- A lifetime gift of the quotas, with or without reservation of the usufruct. It generally counts towards calculating the other children's forced share if it was made in the ten years before death.
The other children can also be compensated during the parent's lifetime. If they receive assets or money in payment of their future forced share, in a succession agreement or in a gift made by deed, they may waive the right to claim any possible supplement later. Outside cases like this, an advance waiver of the forced share is not valid.
In most of the rest of Spain, the children's forced share is two thirds of the estate and succession agreements are generally not allowed. The Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) does allow, however, a testator who wants to keep the business to order the others' forced share to be paid in cash, with a deferral of up to five years.
What needs to be adjusted in the company
The inheritance decides who receives the quotas, but not how the company will work afterwards. It is advisable to review these points:
- The articles of association. If they say nothing, whoever inherits the quotas becomes a shareholder. They can give the remaining shareholders the right to acquire the deceased's quotas by paying their fair value, which is or is not desirable depending on who is to carry on.
- The management. If the founder is the sole director, provision must be made for who can act when he or she is gone, for example by appointing another director or a substitute during the founder's lifetime.
- The family protocol or the shareholders' agreement, with the rules on the work of family members in the business, dividends and the exit of anyone who wants to sell.
The tax calculation for each option, including the allowances provided for family businesses, is a separate matter and should be done before deciding.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.