What is the time limit for claiming for hidden defects in a commercial sale?
Thirty days from delivery is the time limit that the “Código de Comercio”, the Commercial Code, gives for claiming against the seller for internal defects, which are defects that cannot be seen when the goods are examined. For defects of quantity or quality that can be seen, the time limit is four days if the goods arrived packed. Anyone who does not claim in time loses the right, unless what was delivered is something different from what was agreed or is wholly unusable, which is treated as a breach of contract and has a longer time limit. Where the buyer claims in time and there is no agreement, it is advisable to sue within the six months following delivery. In a civil sale the time limits are much longer, above all in Catalonia.
Alburquerque Abogados
The time limits in the Commercial Code
These time limits apply only to a commercial sale, that is, a sale of movable goods bought for resale. The law distinguishes three situations:
- If the buyer examines the goods on receiving them and accepts them as satisfactory, the buyer can no longer claim afterwards for defects of quantity or quality that the examination would have revealed.
- If the buyer receives them packed, the buyer can claim for those defects within four days following the day of receipt. The seller can prevent this by requiring the goods to be examined at the moment of delivery.
- If the defect is internal, that is, it is not apparent on a normal examination, the buyer has thirty days from delivery.
The courts take the view that these are time limits for making a claim to the seller, not for suing. A written complaint describing the defect is enough, sent by a means that leaves a record, such as a “burofax” (a certified letter with proof of content). The thirty days run from delivery, not from when the defect is discovered. Public holidays count too. That is why it is advisable to test the goods as soon as they arrive.
Claiming in time preserves the right, but not indefinitely. For bringing the claim, the courts have been applying the six-month period from delivery that the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) gives for hidden defects, which a simple letter may not stop. The prudent course, in Catalonia too, is to sue before those six months have passed if there is no agreement. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
If the contract or the conditions of sale set a longer guarantee or claim period, what was agreed applies. Between businesses the parties may also shorten the statutory periods or limit the guarantee, so it is advisable to check them straight away.
If what is delivered is something else or is unusable
The four-day and thirty-day periods do not apply when the seller delivers something different from what was agreed or something so defective that it is of no use at all for its purpose. The courts call this “aliud pro alio”, one thing for another. They treat it as a breach of contract, as if what was sold had not been delivered at all. The buyer can then demand what was agreed or terminate the contract, that is, undo it. In both cases the buyer can also claim damages. The period is the general one for claims for breach of contract, which is counted in years.
The line between a serious defect and an unusable item is decided by the judge in each case, so the prudent course is always to claim within thirty days and to sue within six months if there is no agreement.
In a civil sale
If the sale is not commercial, for example because the goods were not bought for resale, the time limits are different:
- In Catalonia the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, applies. For purchases made from 1 January 2022, the seller is liable for defects that already existed at the moment of delivery and appear within the following three years. The buyer must notify the seller without unjustified delay, but a buyer who is late does not lose the right and is liable only for the harm the delay causes. To claim, the buyer has three years from when the defect is discovered or could have been discovered.
- In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code gives six months from delivery to claim for hidden defects.
As it is not always clear whether a purchase between businesses is commercial or civil, if in doubt it is advisable to claim within the time limits of the Commercial Code.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.