What liability does the seller of a business have for hidden defects?
It depends on what has been bought and, above all, on what the contract says. If the shares or quotas (“participaciones”) in the company are bought, what is sold is the shares or quotas themselves and not the assets of the business, so treating debts or problems that come to light in the business later as hidden defects is doubtful. The courts do not always accept it and, under the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”), the time limit for claiming for hidden defects is only six months from delivery. That is why the buyer's protection lies mainly in the seller's representations and warranties, that is, the seller's statements about the state of the business, with the indemnity provided for in the contract if they prove untrue. Without those clauses, the buyer can claim if deceived by the seller, but will have to prove it.
Alburquerque Abogados
Why hidden defects are a poor fit
The Spanish Civil Code makes the seller liable for hidden defects in the thing sold that make it unfit for its use or that, had they been known, would have led the buyer not to buy or to pay less. The buyer can undo the sale or ask for a reduction in the price. If the seller knew of the defect and kept quiet about it, the buyer can also claim damages when undoing the sale.
That rule is designed for things, such as a machine or business premises. When quotas are bought, a tax debt that comes to light later is not, strictly speaking, a defect in the quotas but in the net worth of the company, which is still the debtor. The courts have given different answers in these cases. The seller's statements about the position of the business, on the other hand, are treated as an agreed warranty, governed by what the contract says.
If what is bought is the business itself, that is, its assets, the seller is liable for defects in each of them under the rules on sale. In Catalonia, when the sale is governed by the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, those rules do not speak of hidden defects but of lack of conformity with what was agreed. For purchases made since 2022, the seller is liable for defects that existed at delivery and appear within the following three years. The buyer has three years to claim from when the buyer becomes aware or could have become aware of the problem. In most of the rest of Spain the six-month period from delivery applies.
What really protects the buyer
Representations and warranties are statements by the seller about the business at the time of the sale, for example that the accounts reflect its true position, that it has no debts other than those shown in them or that there are no pending lawsuits or inspections. If any of them proves untrue, the seller indemnifies the buyer on the agreed terms, even if the seller did not know, subject to the limits on amount and time set by the contract.
Those limits do not protect a seller who knowingly conceals a problem, because the law does not allow the right to claim for deception to be waived in advance. The fact that the buyer has reviewed the business does not, by itself, release the seller from the statements made. Even so, if the buyer knew of a problem from the review, it is debatable whether the buyer can claim for it, so it is advisable for the contract to say what happens with known risks.
If the contract says nothing
Without those clauses, the buyer has other remedies, which are harder to prove:
- Deception, which the law calls “dolo”. If the seller concealed debts or problems that should have been disclosed and the purchase would not have been made without that deception, the buyer can ask for the sale to be annulled. If the deception only affected the terms, the buyer can claim damages.
- Mistake. If the buyer bought because of a significant and excusable mistake about the position of the business, the buyer can apply for annulment.
- Breach of contract. Only in extreme cases, where the business delivered is so different from what was agreed that it is of no use for the purpose for which it was bought, do the courts treat it as if what was sold had not been delivered, which allows the contract to be terminated and damages to be claimed. The appearance of debts is not enough if the business is still operating.
Annulment can be sought within four years of the contract being fully performed. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.