When is a court-appointed representative (“defensor judicial”) needed?

When a minor's interests clash in a specific matter with those of the people who represent them and there is no other representative free of that conflict. The “defensor judicial” is a court-appointed representative who acts for the minor in that matter. If the conflict is with one of the parents and both exercise parental authority (“patria potestad”), the other parent represents the child, with no need for an appointment. One is also appointed when a minor's guardian is not performing their duties and, if necessary, until the guardianship has been set up. The law also provides for one in the case of adults who need support to exercise their legal capacity.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Conflict with the parents

The “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, which calls parental authority “potestad parental”, excludes from the parents' representation any acts in which they have a conflict of interest with the child. If both exercise parental authority and the conflict is with only one of them, the other represents the child. If it is with both or with the only parent who exercises it, a court-appointed representative must be named.

There may be a conflict of interest, for example, in the following cases:

  • The division of an estate in which both the child and their father or mother are heirs.
  • The sale of an asset between the child and their father or mother, or the division of an asset that belongs to both.
  • The child's renunciation of an inheritance or another right where their share ends up with the parent who represents them.
  • A lawsuit between the child and their father or mother.

In most of the rest of Spain the applicable code is the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”), which resolves the conflict in the same way.

Other cases

In Catalonia, a minor under guardianship is also given a court-appointed representative when the minor's interests clash with those of the guardian or when the guardian is not performing their duties. One is likewise appointed, if the minor's circumstances so require, until the minor's guardianship has been set up.

The Spanish Civil Code provides for one in similar cases and also for an emancipated minor who needs their capacity to be supplemented for a particular act, when the person who should do so cannot or has interests opposed to theirs.

In addition, procedural law provides for a court-appointed representative for a minor who is being sued, or who would suffer serious harm if they did not bring a claim, when their parents or guardian are absent and their whereabouts are unknown, refuse to represent them or are unable to do so.

The law also provides for one in the case of adults who need support to exercise their legal capacity, for example when the person providing that support has a conflict of interest with them, which is a separate matter.

How the representative is appointed and what they do

The appointment is made by the court clerk (“letrado de la Administración de Justicia”), who runs the court office. The competent court is the one for the place where the minor lives or the one dealing with the matter that requires the appointment. It can be requested by the father or mother, the minor, the Public Prosecutor's Office (“Ministerio Fiscal”) or any person acting in the minor's interest. It can also be ordered by the court of its own motion. Neither a lawyer nor a court agent (“procurador”) is needed.

Before deciding, the court clerk summons the parties concerned, the Public Prosecutor's Office and the minor if they are sufficiently mature and, in any event, if they are over twelve. The clerk appoints the person considered most suitable for the matter and sets out their powers. In cases of conflict of interest, the representative takes part only in the acts for which they were appointed and, once finished, must give an account of what they have done.

From 4 February 2027, the Catalan Civil Code applies the same rules to the court-appointed representative for minors and to that for adults who need support. Conflicts between parents and child continue to be resolved in the same way.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.