Do you need court authorisation to renounce an inheritance on behalf of a minor?
Yes, parents need the court's authorisation to renounce an inheritance on behalf of their minor child. The judge only grants it if the renunciation is beneficial or necessary for the child. In Catalonia it is not needed if the child is at least sixteen and consents to the renunciation before a notary, or if the child's two closest relatives consent to it before a notary. There, moreover, a minor always inherits with the benefit of inventory, without being liable for the deceased's debts with their own assets, so renouncing is not always in the child's interest. If the renunciation benefits the father or mother who represents the child, a court-appointed representative (“defensor judicial”) may also be needed.
Alburquerque Abogados
When the judge authorises the renunciation
In Catalonia, parents who exercise parental authority (“patria potestad”), which the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, calls “potestad parental”, need court authorisation to renounce an inheritance, a legacy or a gift on the child's behalf. The judge grants it in the child's interest, if the renunciation is beneficial or necessary and this is justified, after hearing the “Ministerio Fiscal”, the Public Prosecutor's Office. The application explains why it is advisable to renounce and gives details of the estate, such as its assets and its known debts. If the judge refuses authorisation, the inheritance is deemed to have been accepted on the child's behalf.
The authorisation can be replaced by consent to the renunciation, given before a notary in a public deed, by the child if they are at least sixteen or by their two closest blood relatives, one on the father's side and one on the mother's side.
In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) also requires court authorisation to renounce an inheritance on the child's behalf. It only dispenses with it if the child is sixteen and consents in a public document. If the judge refuses it, the inheritance can only be accepted with the benefit of inventory.
Renouncing or accepting with the benefit of inventory
In Catalonia, heirs who are minors always have the benefit of inventory, even if they have not asked for it. They are liable for the deceased's debts only with the assets they inherit and never with their own.
That is why the fact that the estate has debts is not in itself enough reason to renounce. If there is doubt about what will be left after paying them, accepting allows the child to keep whatever remains. If it is clear that the debts exceed the assets, renouncing spares the child from having to deal with an estate that will leave them nothing.
What counts is the child's interest. The fact that the renunciation favours other relatives is not enough for the judge to authorise it. The tax implications of accepting or renouncing are another matter.
If the father or mother also inherits
Sometimes the share the child renounces ends up with the father or mother who represents the child. This happens, for example, when the other parent dies without a will and their estate is governed by Catalan law. If all the children renounce while the surviving spouse or stable partner (“pareja estable”, Catalan stable partnership) who is the father or mother of all of them is still alive, the estate does not pass to the grandchildren but goes to him or her.
In such cases there is a conflict of interest. If both parents exercise parental authority and the conflict is with only one of them, the other represents the child. If it is with both or with the only parent who exercises it, the court clerk (“letrado de la Administración de Justicia”) names a court-appointed representative, a person who represents the minor in that matter alone. In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code resolves the conflict in the same way.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.