What happens to your car under the Second Chance Law (“Ley de Segunda Oportunidad”)?

It depends on the route chosen and on whether the car has been paid off. With a payment plan, which allows the creditors to be paid over a number of years without selling the assets, you can keep it, although if any creditor objects, the plan must give the creditors at least what they would obtain by selling it. If the assets are liquidated, the car is sold along with the others, unless the judge regards it as a work tool protected from attachment or all your assets are worth so little that it is not worth selling them. If you are still paying for it and the finance company retained ownership until the last instalment, with the retention registered in the “Registro de Bienes Muebles”, Spain's register of movable property, the finance company is paid first out of the car, so the usual way to keep it is to keep paying the instalments.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

With a payment plan

The second chance, which the law calls the discharge of unsatisfied liabilities (“exoneración del pasivo insatisfecho”), that is, the write-off of the debts that remain unpaid, can be applied for with a payment plan of three or five years in which the assets are kept, including the car. If any creditor challenges the plan, the law sets two limits:

  • The judge will not approve a plan that gives the creditors less than they would receive if the assets were sold. The value of the car counts in that calculation.
  • If the car is not needed for your professional or business activity, creditors representing at least 40 % of the debts that can be cancelled can object to a plan that does not provide for its sale.

An old car or one of little value carries little weight in that calculation. A high-value car may mean having to pay more under the plan or having to sell it.

If the assets are liquidated

If the second chance is applied for with liquidation, the car is one of the assets that are sold to pay the creditors. There are two cases in which it may not be sold:

  • If it is equipment needed for your profession or trade and its value is out of proportion to what you owe. The law then treats it as exempt from attachment and it falls outside the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”). The judge assesses this case by case and accepts it more readily when the vehicle is the very tool of the trade than when it is only used to get to work.
  • If all your assets are worth so little that selling them would cost more than it would raise. The law then allows the insolvency proceedings to be conducted without liquidating them, which is known as insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”).

If you are self-employed and your business does not exceed the limits for a micro-enterprise, the route is the special procedure for micro-enterprises (“procedimiento especial para microempresas”) rather than insolvency proceedings, which is a separate matter.

If you are still paying for it

If you bought the car in instalments or with a loan from the finance company and the contract included a retention of title clause (“reserva de dominio”), under which the car is not yours until you finish paying for it, or a prohibition on selling it, registered in the register of movable property, the finance company has priority to be paid out of the value of the car. To keep it, you will normally have to keep paying the instalments. If it is sold, the finance company is paid first and whatever remains unpaid of its debt is cancelled along with the others.

If the loan did not have that security, it is just another debt and the car is an asset like any other. If the car is on an operating lease (“renting”) or a finance lease (“leasing”), it belongs to the company that provides it to you. What happens to it depends on the contract, which is a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.