Can I be sued after using the Second Chance Law (“Ley de Segunda Oportunidad”)?

Not for the debts that have been written off. The law bars creditors from taking any action to collect them, including any fund that has bought the debt, which has no more rights than the bank that sold it. You can, however, be sued for debts that the second chance procedure does not cancel, such as maintenance payments or the part of public-law debts (owed to the tax authorities and Social Security) above the statutory limit. You can also be sued for debts you take on afterwards. In addition, for three years any affected creditor can ask the judge to revoke the write-off in cases strictly laid down by law, such as having concealed assets or receiving an inheritance that enables you to pay.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Debts that have been written off

The second chance procedure, which the law calls the discharge of unsatisfied liabilities (“exoneración del pasivo insatisfecho”), that is, the write-off of the debts that remain unpaid, extinguishes the debts it covers. The creditors cannot take any action against you to collect them. They can only ask the judge to revoke the write-off in the cases provided for by law.

If the bank sold the debt to a fund, the fund is in the same position, because whoever buys a debt acquires no more rights than the seller had.

The write-off does not extend to your guarantors or to anyone who signed the debt with you, from whom the creditor can still claim. If a guarantor pays, they will generally not be able to claim back from you what they paid either, because the law extends the write-off to that reimbursement.

If they keep claiming the debt

A fund or a debt collection agency may keep claiming a debt that has been written off, for example because the discharge does not appear in its systems. It is advisable to act as follows:

  • Reply in writing, by a means that leaves a record, enclosing a copy of the court decision granting the discharge. Ask them to stop claiming and to remove you from the registers of bad debtors (“ficheros de morosos”).
  • If you receive a demand from the court in an order for payment procedure (“proceso monitorio”), the fast-track procedure for debt claims, do not ignore it. You have twenty working days to file an objection relying on the discharge, with a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”) if more than 2.000 euros is being claimed. If you do not object, the court will close the procedure, the creditor will be able to apply for attachment and you will not be able to recover afterwards, in other proceedings, what is collected from you.
  • If you are sued, rely on the discharge in your defence and provide the court decision. The judge cannot take it into account without knowing about it.

When they can still claim from you

The discharge does not prevent every claim. You can be sued or have your assets attached in these cases:

  • For debts that the law excludes from the write-off, such as maintenance payments, compensation arising from a criminal offence or the part of public-law debts above the statutory limit. Those creditors keep their rights of action.
  • For debts you take on after obtaining the discharge.
  • If the judge revokes the write-off. Any affected creditor can apply for this within three years of its being granted if it comes to light that you concealed assets, rights or income, if during that time your situation improves substantially thanks to an inheritance, a legacy, a gift or a gambling win that enables you to pay, or if a final conviction or penalty is imposed in certain proceedings that were already under way. Once it is revoked, the debts that were written off can be claimed again, in whole or in part.
  • If you obtained the write-off with a payment plan and do not comply with it. Any affected creditor can then ask for the provisional discharge to be revoked.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.