Is the Second Chance Law (“Ley de Segunda Oportunidad”) reliable?
Yes, in the sense that it is a mechanism regulated by the Insolvency Act (“Ley Concursal”) and the write-off of the debts is granted by a judge, with effects that creditors must respect. What is not reliable is the promise that all debts will be cancelled unconditionally, because the write-off is not automatic. It is obtained only by those who meet the requirements, does not cover some debts or guarantors and can be revoked if it later emerges, for example, that the debtor concealed assets. Before you start, it is advisable to know, on the facts of your case, what you can achieve and what you cannot.
Alburquerque Abogados
What provides certainty
The discharge of unsatisfied liabilities, which is the legal name for the write-off of debts, is applied for within insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) and decided by the judge. If you are self-employed and your business does not exceed the limits for a micro-enterprise, the route is not insolvency proceedings but the special procedure for micro-enterprises (“procedimiento especial para microempresas”), which is a separate matter. On the liquidation route, creditors can only object by arguing that a legal requirement is not met. On the payment plan route they have somewhat more leeway, because they can challenge the plan on the grounds laid down by law, for example if it gives them less than they would receive from the sale of the debtor's assets.
Once it has been granted, creditors cannot claim the written-off debts by any means, either in court or out of court. If any creditor tries to, the judge's decision proves that the debt is no longer owed.
The procedure also has its formal safeguards. The law requires the debtor to act in the insolvency proceedings through a court agent (“procurador”) and a lawyer. The proceedings are handled by the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”), which is the one that specialises in this area.
What nobody can promise
There are several reasons why the outcome cannot be guaranteed in advance:
- The requirements. The judge refuses the discharge if the debtor is in any of the situations excluded by law, such as certain convictions or very serious penalties in the previous ten years, insolvency proceedings classified as culpable or having incurred debts through deception or recklessness.
- Excluded debts. Some are never written off, such as maintenance payments or compensation arising from a criminal offence. Debts owed to the tax authorities and Social Security are only written off up to certain limits.
- Third parties. The write-off does not release guarantors or those who signed the debt together with the debtor.
- Revocation. For three years creditors can ask for it to be set aside, among other cases, if it emerges that the debtor concealed assets or income or if the debtor's financial situation improves considerably through an inheritance, a gift or gambling winnings. With a payment plan, also if the debtor fails to comply with it.
How to avoid surprises
Be wary of anyone who assures you that all your debts will be cancelled or gives you a fixed timescale without knowing your case. Before engaging anyone to handle it, ask for a written explanation of which route suits you, which debts will be excluded, what may happen to your assets and how much the procedure will cost, with a full breakdown.
Also check who will be the lawyer signing the pleadings and that they are registered with the Bar Association, because that lawyer is answerable for your defence before the judge. In addition, give full information about your assets, income and debts from the outset, because concealing anything may cost you the write-off or lead to its later revocation.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.