What happens if my application under the Second Chance Law (“Ley de Segunda Oportunidad”) is refused?
Your debts remain yours, including those that would have been written off. When the insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) end, creditors will be able to pursue you again and apply for the attachment of your assets and of the attachable part of your income, without having to bring new court proceedings if they appear on the final list of creditors in the insolvency proceedings. If the judge refuses the write-off by a judgment, following an objection by a creditor or by the insolvency practitioner, an appeal can be brought. If what is revoked or never becomes final is a write-off obtained with a payment plan, the law still allows you to apply for it through the route of selling your assets.
Alburquerque Abogados
Why it is refused
The judge refuses the discharge of unsatisfied liabilities, which is the write-off of the debts that remain unpaid, when a legal requirement is missing. It may be that you are in one of the situations excluded by law, such as a conviction or a very serious penalty in the previous ten years, insolvency proceedings classified as culpable or having incurred debts through deception or recklessness. It may also be that you have recently obtained another discharge.
On the payment plan route there are also specific grounds. Creditors can challenge the plan, for example if it gives them less than they would receive from the sale of your assets or if it does not allocate to the debts what you earn above the amount protected by law and what is reasonable for your expenses and obligations.
What happens to your debts
If the write-off was being sought at the end of the liquidation of your assets or in insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”), the judge closes the proceedings without writing anything off. You still owe whatever was not paid and creditors can apply for the attachment of your assets and of the attachable part of your income for as long as the insolvency proceedings are not reopened. For those who appear on the final list of creditors, that inclusion serves as a final judgment, so they do not need new court proceedings to apply for attachment.
If the write-off was being sought with a payment plan, the situation is different:
- If the judge does not approve the plan, the insolvency proceedings continue and, in principle, you will be able to apply for the write-off through the liquidation route, provided that the reason for the rejection does not rule that out as well.
- If the provisional write-off is revoked because you do not comply with the plan, the plan is terminated and the liquidation of your assets is opened. Whatever has already been paid under the plan remains validly paid, except in the case of fraud or acts contrary to the plan. The law then allows you to apply for the write-off through the liquidation route.
- If the final write-off cannot be granted when the plan ends, the law also allows you to apply for it through the liquidation route.
What you can do
If the refusal comes because a creditor or the insolvency practitioner objected, the judge orders it by a judgment, which can be appealed to the “Audiencia Provincial”, the provincial appeal court. The judgment ruling on challenges to the payment plan can also be appealed, although the appeal does not suspend what has been decided. The time limits for appealing are short, so it is advisable to assess this with your lawyer as soon as you receive the decision.
Some grounds for refusal cease to count over time or once payment is made. Convictions and very serious penalties only count for ten years. Penalties, moreover, no longer prevent the write-off if they are paid in full before it is applied for. The law only sets waiting periods for reapplying for the discharge for those who have already obtained it, not for those who were refused it. If circumstances change, it is advisable to look into whether another attempt is possible. In the meantime, nothing prevents you from negotiating payment in instalments or a reduction of the debt with the creditors.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.